THE LAST WORD

Women’s choice to work: A clash of liberal ideals

There's no particular reason why more women should go out to work. Or, alternatively, richer countries have more women working so therefore more women should work to make Bangladesh richer. Between those two statements is one of the grand differences between what is called modern liberalism and being truly liberal. 

As the World Bank points out: “Female labour force participation in South Asia is among the lowest in the world.” Ok. Now, this difference between the two types of liberalism is not what we do about this. It's whether we do anything at all about it. 

On the one side, the modern liberal. We want to grow the economy, that means more people working in the market, paid, economy. So therefore more women should go to work. We must change society so that more do. So, we have paid childcare -- even if that's paid for through taxation and so free to individuals -- and encouragement to women to go out to work and so on. 

We also tend to get insistences that a gender pay gap is proof that this isn't happening, or not fairly. And that a drop in female labour force participation is proof of failure and so on. If women aren't acting, and working, as men are then that's proof perfect of a lack of gender equality.  

Then there are the proper, real, liberals like me. Actually, even among classical liberals I'm a bit lonely in what follows. 

Yes, of course, each and every adult must have that freedom to live their lives as they wish. Restrictions -- in law or pay or job choice -- based upon gender are as vile as basing it upon race or that appalling Indian habit of doing so upon caste. But, and here's the thing, it's the freedom that is necessary, not the output or the equal result.

It's that last where the two forms of liberalism differ. Much of the modern world insists upon the outcome being the thing. That, say, lots of women take advantage of free childcare and go out to work for money. 

The other sort of liberal says that if that's what they want to do then that's just fine. Not just fine, it's glorious even. But that other kind of liberal also says that if they don't want to then that's also fine -- glorious even.  

They’re attempts to impose an end result upon us rather than society being the exercise of our freedoms

That is, there's no plan for society or what it should look like. Only that everyone should be able to live their lives as they wish and as long as there's no third party harm to their choices then each and every outcome is equally glorious. 

It is, after all, possible to get too excited about GDP itself. Yes, if women go out to work for money and other women are employed to take care of their children then GDP rises. But we might not have really seen any real increase in economic activity properly defined -- the same number of children are still being looked after, just not by their mothers and for money not love. 

The point here is not that mothers should, or should not, stay at home -- that's absolutely their choice. But whatever that choice does to GDP isn't a real change in economic activity, the change in GDP is just an artefact of how we measure economic activity. 

As long as we've all the freedoms to do it our way then society at the end is just the aggregate of what we all get up to. And because that society at the end is that aggregate of all our freedoms then it's just fine -- even glorious.

Which gives us a method of judging the proposals put before us. If they regard increases in those freedoms then that's great. If they’re targets -- for, say, female labour force participation -- then they're not great, for they’re attempts to impose an end result upon us rather than society being the exercise of our freedoms. 

One little data point here. Italy has a much lower gender pay gap than near all of Europe. This is, by that modern liberal measure, a good thing. It's also true that Italy has a very low labour force participation among married women, especially those with children. This is, by modern liberalism, a bad thing. 

But they are the same thing. Married women, likely with problems over childcare and so on, tend not to work. Therefore wages are not badly hit by those childcare problems. Now, whether that's a good idea or not isn't for you or me to decide -- so long as women get to live their lives as they wish there.

But to modern liberals that's a problem -- which is one of those problems with modern liberalism. They have targets for what they think are good things when the only useful target is that people have the freedom to choose what they, themselves, think are good lives.

Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.