Why do we need a separate shuttle for women?

Incidents of harassment against women in the streets have increased alarmingly, leaving many concerned about the worsening safety conditions. Amid this growing anxiety, a women-only shuttle service has been announced to launch in Dhaka, quickly gaining attention on social media as a promising step toward addressing women’s safety and transportation challenges.

The founder of the initiative stated that their goal is to introduce a transportation network that ensures women’s safety while remaining affordable. She highlighted that the service aims to provide a safe and convenient alternative for women navigating the chaotic streets of Dhaka, rather than merely facilitating travel from point A to point B. The messaging resonated with many women, symbolizing solidarity and support for women’s safety. However, despite the initial enthusiasm, the shuttle’s pricing model has generated widespread criticism.

At a steep rate of Tk500 for a round trip on a daily basis, the service is beyond the reach of most women, raising serious questions about its accessibility and effectiveness. Critics have been quick to point out that women who can afford such a service are likely already shielded from the daily dangers of public transport. Thus, it appears that the business caters to a privileged few, leaving behind the majority of women who face harassment and violence in public transportation. 

The most vocal criticisms on social media platforms highlighted how a capitalistic approach to women’s safety inevitably fails to address the root cause of the issue. Many argued that the commodification of women's safety not only alienates those most in need but also exploits women’s struggles solely for profit.

But beyond the capitalist critique lies a more important question: why do we need a separate bus service for women in the first place? 

Is segregation the answer to the systemic violence women face? By isolating women in “pink” shuttles, in “women-only” BRTC buses, and in designated seats, are we addressing the root of the problem, or merely reinforcing patriarchal norms that suggest women must be shielded, hidden, and separated to remain safe?

Our collective reliance on such segregated solutions is, in itself, problematic. By introducing gender-segregated transport, we essentially absolve the state of its responsibility to create safe and inclusive public spaces. Instead of focusing on law enforcement reforms, stricter penalties for perpetrators, and social awareness to change misogynist mindsets, we offer women a segregated solution. 

This not only fails to address the root causes of harassment and violence women face but also reinforces a culture where women are seen as liabilities needing separation to be safe rather than equal citizens entitled to occupy public spaces freely.

But let us ask ourselves: Does reaching a destination in a separate bus genuinely address the harassment and violence women face? 

If we start isolating women in transportation, what’s next -- separate offices to prevent workplace harassment? 

Shall we create female-only markets or segregated government services to shield women from every possible interaction with men? 

What, then, do we do about the violence women face in private domains -- create separate private spaces too? 

This trend of isolating women in the public sphere does not solve the issue of violence; it merely offers a temporary solution, failing to address the structural causes rooted in misogyny and patriarchal entitlement. Before we succumb to the allure of such “solutions,” we must question each remedy patriarchy proposes for problems it has inherently created.

Such women-only buses, while branded as a solution to women’s safety, mirrors this discriminatory trend, forcing women to pay more for the basic right to move safely in public spaces

It is understandable, of course, that many women may find comfort in these “pink” solutions. After enduring relentless harassment in public spaces on a daily basis, many might embrace any opportunity for relief, even if it does not address the root cause. But these segregative measures do not help women in the long term. 

Women should not have to segregate themselves in order to navigate public spaces safely. They deserve the right to move freely in all public areas, exercising their constitutional rights as citizens of Bangladesh without fear of violence or harassment. The state has the responsibility to ensure that these spaces are safe for every woman, not just those who can afford a premium service.

The cost of being a woman is not a new phenomenon. Globally, we’ve seen the “pink tax” -- the inflated prices of products and services marketed specifically to women. Bangladesh is no exception. 

Such women-only buses, while branded as a solution to women’s safety, mirrors this discriminatory trend, forcing women to pay more for the basic right to move safely in public spaces. 

Like other gendered products, such “women-only” businesses exploit women’s vulnerabilities for profit while masquerading as a solution to their struggles. It is yet another example of how capitalist systems capitalize on existing inequalities, offering solutions that seem helpful but ultimately reinforce and profit from the problems they exploit.

The real solution to women’s safety is not segregation but integration. Women must boldly claim their rightful place in all public spaces. And it is the state’s duty to enforce laws and create an environment where no man dares to assault a woman. Safety should not be a privilege afforded to those women who can pay for it; it should be a right guaranteed to all.

The newly independent Bangladesh offers us an opportunity to reimagine the role of women in public life. Yet even in the formation of the interim government, women remain grossly underrepresented, with only four out of sixteen advisors being women -- a tokenistic gesture, at best. 

When we have raised our voices against such exclusions, we have been told to be patient, that now is not the time to demand our rights. But after a decade and a half of silence, the consequences of inaction are clear. Now, more than ever, is the time for us to demand our safety, representation, and equity in all public domains.

It is time for us to be critical of all “pink” traps created by capitalism and patriarchy alike. True solution will come not from isolating women, but from systemic change -- change that empowers women to exist freely and safely in all spaces, without having to pay the price for their gender.

Nabila Tasneem Anonnya is a researcher and a women's rights activist.