Bangladesh is to ban plastic bags at all markets. To get to grips with this idea we need the concept of Chesterton's Fence.
GK Chesterton was a writer of perhaps a century ago, now possibly best known for the Father Brown novels. Back then he was quite the major journalist of the age. He had a very strange line in economics -- he and his friend Hilaire Belloc came up with something verging on, in economic terms alone, Catholic fascism which is not a good mixture of ideas. But his idea of the fence is still extremely useful.
Imagine we are in a field observing a fence. We decide that, thoroughly modern and clever as we are, we should tear the fence down. Not so fast -- we've got to work out why the fence was put up in the first place before taking action. For only if we know why the fence was constructed can we work out whether that reason is still valid. Or not, as the case may be.
So, if polythene and polypropylene bags are to be banned, then we are being very modern and clever in doing this. Even the “experts” argue that the damages are “undeniable.” But it is still true that our forebears, our ancestors, started to use plastic bags. Why did they do so? Until we know that we can't work out whether that reason still applies or not.
No, it's not good enough to say that plastic bags float around the environment. That's an argument for making sure that they're collected. No, that they don't rot isn't a reason -- they're made of oil, we can burn them at the cost of some toxic fumes.
It's entirely possible to think of a system that would deal with this -- pay one Taka when getting a new bag, collectors of rubbish in the streets are given one Taka when they hand one in at the power station. OK, perhaps a little more detail required but you get the idea. Some call it recycling.
The article telling us about the ban gives us a clue or two. There are people trying to make plastics from cassava, from jute. True, this is Bangladesh so there's always someone telling us that jute will be useful once again. But these alternatives are more expensive. We could go back to using paper maybe, but that destroys trees that take less time to grow than the oil that produces plastics.
It's not good enough to say that plastic bags float around the environment
All of this gives us one set of reasons why plastics began to be used. They're cheap-cheap. Really cheap compared to the alternatives.
The other reason was that the alternatives aren't as effective. It really is true that using single use plastics for food reduces both food waste and food poisoning. In Britain there are regular warnings about people putting unwrapped and raw chicken into their reusable shopping bags then a week later catching salmonella as they use the bag again. What seems like the very weird practice of wrapping a cucumber in plastic actually does extend the shelf life from two or three days to 10 or 12.
Which is the thing about plastics and why our ancestors adopted them. They work. They wrap and carry and protect, and they're cheap. None of which has changed. Therefore, our discussion about tearing down the fence is incomplete, isn't it? We've not found that the reason for using plastics has gone away. Therefore it might well be an error -- it'll certainly make us poorer -- to stop using them.
Chesterton's Fence is one of those logical tools we really must learn to apply every time one of those moderns -- oh so clever as I am -- tells us we've got to stop doing something. Well, why did we start doing it? Does that reason still exist? So why should we stop?
Sometimes stopping doing something is a really great idea. Everywhere that stopped doing socialism let out a great sigh of relief at doing so. But we still need to check.
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.