Youth and its discontents

China's got a problem with youth unemployment -- which, for an economy growing quickly and also facing population decline, is a truly odd set of circumstances. Now, it is possible to shrug, even laugh, at the problems being faced by some other country, and while we might even do that it is certainly not kind. No, go on, give in, snigger -- but then I hope you feel guilty about it. Rather, more importantly, we need to make sure that we don't make the same mistake. 

This newspaper has reported on the problem and to me this is the most important line: “The number of new Chinese startups has fallen by 97% over the past six years, the British business daily Financial Times reported this week -- from over 51,000 in 2018 to some 1,200 last year.” 

Now, the way China managed this is important -- they moved away from capitalism. The true and basic idea there -- leave all that Marxist rubbish to one side -- is that the people with money risk it on new ideas. They fund folk trying to build some new company, if it works then they get some to all of the profit. If it doesn't work then of course they lose it. But the one big important word there is “risk.”

What China has done is change the rules. Those who are trying to start a company are personally responsible for paying back that investment. That is, suddenly, risk capital has been converted into a repayable loan. It has changed those rules from capitalism to banking. That doesn't work for people taking the risks to start new companies. It doesn't work because those young lads trying to do something new simply stop doing so.   

At which point two really important things come up: First, economic growth is the speed at which we do new things. No, really, it is. Sure, it's possible to just do more and more of the same old things. Use more inputs -- labour, minerals, land -- to just increase production. That's how the Soviet Union worked and that didn't, in the end, work out well. Over the 20th century, the market economies produced about 80% of their growth from doing new things -- or old things in new ways. This means change, obviously. But economists' special word here is “productivity.” We get more of what we want by using less, or fewer, of those resources because we're using new ways. The speed at which we do this is, itself, the speed of economic growth. 

The reason that capitalism and markets work at this economic growth thing is that the capitalists risk their money on these new ways and new ways are therefore tested, tried, and sorted into those that work and those that don't. We do more of those that do and that's the growth. If the risk is replaced with bankers worrying about getting their loans back then this process doesn't happen.

The second is that in this process of increasing productivity we end up using fewer of those economic resources. One of which is, obviously, human labour. In the end this is what makes us all richer. For the obvious reason that if each hour of human labour produces more value then each hour of human labour can be paid more -- and in a market economy it will be too.

So we end up with a problem. If we have an economy doing that desirable thing of making us richer by requiring less labour, fewer inputs, then we end up with an unemployment problem. Because each hour of labour now produces more, we need fewer hours of labour to produce the same old stuff, right? Well, yes, right.

The answer to which is that sure, we will all -- and we do, this has been going on for centuries -- take some of that now spare time as leisure. But what we don't want is that the young all have to take forced leisure as unemployment instead of all of us having a slightly shorter working week. So, how do we deal with this?

Well, we have got to have that thriving sector trying out new things to do in new ways. When people find new things -- sensible new things -- to do then that's one of the things that makes us richer. We get to enjoy those new things. But it's also what cures that unemployment problem -- that spare labour left over from increasing productivity gets to go work doing those new things. 

We really do want productivity to increase. For that's what makes us all richer. But productivity increases, by definition, leave us with too much labour. We want that now excess labour to do new things -- which is where capitalism comes in, funding the experiments into useful new things being done. China's new youth unemployment problem is the result of an insufficiency of capitalism funding new ventures. 

Now, where do we know that has students complaining about the difficulty of getting a job these days? Hmm, ahh … more free market capitalism then, eh?  

Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.