Ilish export: More questions than answers

The current government is facing a colossal challenge. Muhammad Yunus, serving as Bangladesh’s Chief Adviser of the current interim government, has consistently stressed the need to rebuild the country’s institutions from the ground up, which has been the government’s main focus.

It is safe to say that one of the key difficulties in this rebuilding process is managing the relationship with India.

There’s been no sign that government officials have spoken negatively about India. Instead, they’ve emphasized the importance of a balanced and fair relationship, concentrating on fostering connections between people rather than individual politicians.

However, the general public sentiment has been that this relationship has often seemed one-sided.

Among the contentious issues regarding this relationship has been the export of Ilish to India. In the past, the fish was often sent as “gifts” which angered the general population. When the interim government came to be, people expected no more of the iconic fish to be sent to India.

The Ministry of Livestock and Fisheries took steps to reinforce the Ilish fish export ban, prioritizing domestic consumption over exports. This was also an attempt to shift away from the narrative that Bangladesh always needs to yield to maintain good relations. At a time when Indian politicians have belittled Bangladeshis as "termites," Ilish diplomacy felt like another gesture of submission.

However, just a month and a half later, the policy has changed. Bangladesh now plans to export 3,000 tonnes of Ilish to India.

Though this amount is less than 1% of total production and won’t greatly impact domestic supply or prices, concerns have emerged.

Commerce Adviser Salehuddin Ahmed defended the move, calling it in the "greater interest of the country." While the greater good is important, recent developments still leave some uncertainty and several questions remain.

Here are some of my questions

  1. What exactly is meant by the “greater good?” Are we returning to an era where vague explanations were enough to justify decisions? Why isn’t the public provided with more information? The decision is said to have come from the top. If so, then who made it, and can we get the reasons?
  2. The rhetoric from the Ministry of Livestock and Fisheries has been circulating for some time, and it’s clear the Commerce Ministry was aware of it. Why wasn’t there better coordination between the two ministries? The messaging is inconsistent, and it appears that the Ministry of Livestock and Fisheries is shouldering the blame. Was there no consideration of the consequences of such a sudden policy reversal? Are we cultivating a culture where ministries pass the blame?
  3. If the commerce adviser views the Ministry of Livestock and Fisheries’ stance as "emotional," why wasn’t it addressed earlier? Why is it labelled emotional now?
  4. Is the Commerce Ministry benefiting politically -- perhaps through lower onion export tariffs from India -- while leaving the Ministry of Livestock and Fisheries to face the fallout? If so, why hasn’t this been acknowledged?
  5. Despite the export, Ilish prices aren’t decreasing. Fishermen have reported large-scale smuggling during the previous regime. What is being done to address this?
  6. Finally, why are Ilish prices still high? Is this the new equilibrium price?

It’s evident that the Ilish diplomacy incident has been poorly managed, highlighting significant flaws within this government. This should be seen as an opportunity to address those weaknesses.

This interim government must come to terms with the fact that its strength lies in unity. Hasty decisions that lead to public confusion or embarrassment reflect poorly on the entire administration.

I am confident that, with time and experience, this government will improve and exercise better judgment. However, incidents like this must be avoided in the future. Clear and consistent communication with the public is crucial for maintaining trust and credibility.

Rudashi Ashna Islam is a former worker in the development sector.