Eliminating legal privilege

As we all take account of the last couple of decades in politics and business -- learn the stories of who did what and how -- we are of course less than happy about at least some of what happened. The general growth in the economy, in the wealth of the nation, was nice to have. The activities of S Alam and Salman F Rahman probably less so -- to be very neutral and excessively mild about those matters there.

Clearly, as we move on we want the future to still have that economic growth but we'd very much prefer to have fewer chancers manipulating parts of the financial system. The trick here is to make sure that we get the one not the both -- and the right one of course. 

Warren Buffett has said that it's when the tide goes out that you can see who has been swimming without a bathing suit. This is a general comment on the booms and busts inherent in a market economy. When money's cheap and the economy is roaring then many a bad businesses can stagger on for a bit longer -- it's when that economic tide turns that we can see who will really survive. 

However, we should use the same insight as we try to change the economy in this new status of ours. 

We know that the old ways enabled people to carve out privileged positions for themselves. To be able to borrow with no real need to repay say. Or not paying taxes that were due -- or even at all. This is what privilege in regards to the law means: People connected being treated differently from the rest in their interactions with legality. 

Now, given that we don't like what's being uncovered amongst what did happen, we obviously want to make sure that it doesn't happen in this next world currently under construction. Well, how do we do that?

The first thing we've got to grasp is that we can't just say “Ah, but, now we've got rid of the bad people, so everything will be fine.” That's not how humans work at all. 

What is true, is that, if there is a way to gain that privilege again then people will. 

No, not because good politics will be invaded by bad people. But because there really are people out there who want to have privilege. To not have to obey the same rules as the rest of us. So, if there's an opportunity for them to do that then they will. 

This means that the method of having an honest economy -- with whoever is in political power -- is to have an economy where there's no room to be dishonest. 

Now, obviously, there's always room for people to be simple thieves and so on. We catch them, if we can, and punish them -- obviously. But this system of private law for those who are politically connected -- this can only happen if politics has the power to grant private privileges. 

Say, friends of the ruling political party gain large loans from the state banks but never have to pay them back. Imagine, that such a thing could happen. The prevention is to not have state banks. 

No, it doesn't work if we tell the politicians not to do this. Nor does it work to tell people not to take advantage. We have to remove from the politicians the power over the banks. Then they cannot offer those soft loans and nor can anyone seek them. 

So too remove from politics the ability to offer special tax rates for this activity or other. Or different tariff rates on imports if only people ask the politicians nicely.

Effectively, we have to remove politics from detailed control of the economy. Then those who would seek power or privilege through politics won't even attempt to seek it because they'll not be able to get it. 

That is, a simple set of rules for the economy. Simple taxes, simple rules; taxes and rules that don't vary. The other way of describing this is the rule of law. It's the same for everyone no matter how many politicians you know.

To put it very cynically -- why would anyone buy, bribe, or even befriend politicians if there was nothing that could be bought from politicians? So, the method to clean politics and a clean economy is not to allow politicians to have anything to sell.

 

Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.