Citizens in developing countries have an illusion about states and governments. Because of the developing nature of the economy, governments representing states play a larger-than-life role in allocating resources and play a determining role in the lives of the citizens. Due to a near absence of a robust civil society and an independent judiciary that protects the rights of the citizens, ordinary citizens remain helpless, vulnerable and in need of protection offered by the state.
Sociologists are often spoilers. They bring a less rosy perspective on the state. Charles Tilly, a famous historical sociologist used the word “protection” playfully highlighting both its positive as well as sinister meaning to trace the origin of European states which has some bearing on state-making in the developing countries.
Tilly also linked state-making with war-making and invoked the analogy with mafia and its protection racket. He hastened to add that he was not calling those in charge of state gangsters. But using the ideas of protection and mafia metaphorically.
As local mafia bosses give protection to the local business against petty thugs, the state provides protection against warlords and the stronger warlords after defeating the other contenders. In other words, states are not glorious institutions as portrayed by philosopher GWF Hegel who saw it as the highest manifestation of ethical life.
It is important to recognize that the inspiration of Tilly’s rather practical definition of state is famous German sociologist Max Weber, who defined state as an organization that has the monopoly over the legitimate means of violence in a society.
A failed state is one where there are competing groups who also have command over means of violence. In other words, the state does not have the monopoly and there are groups who try to force their ways with command over illegitimate means of violence.
States which, over the years, have been the poster boys of failed states are those where means of violence are often in the hands of competing groups outside the state. Somalia provides a good example of a failed state since the early 1990s where both internal and external factors, ie US intervention, caused the state to fail. Despite international efforts to rebuild the Somali state, it continues to battle Al-Shabaab, a terrorist group that remains resilient.
To remake or reconstruct a state, it is vital to have a dispassionate view of the state as an organization. For Karl Marx, the state is an instrument in the hands of the capitalist class. When the economy is in crisis which side does the state take? Big banks and industries are bailed out by the governments, representing states, not the members of the working class. One does not have to be a Marxist to see this connection, followers of news know this.
In remaking states, one has to shun idealistic illusions at the very outset. Illusions will bring big time frustrations. State reformers today need not go through the troubles of subduing recalcitrant warlords. They need to focus on the fundamentals. China’s president Xi Jinping, in his address at the World Economic Forum at Davos in 2017, stressed on drawing from its own civilization as well as learning from other successful states from both the West and the East.
Remember, socialist leader Vladimir Lenin had no hesitation in learning from Taylorism, a scientific management technique, which was developed in capitalist countries. It is in that spirit that Chinese paramount leader and reformer Deng Xiaoping famously said, it does not matter if the cat is black or white, as long as it catches the mice.
Pragmatism is key. And pragmatism calls for non-ideological and unsentimental or unemotional approaches. Kishore Mahbubani, a leading intellectual and diplomat of Singapore, often uses his MPH rule which stands for “meritocracy, pragmatism, and honesty” as the basis of success for Singapore. I would change the order a bit. I would put it as HPM. Honesty is the most important foundational principle on which will stand pragmatic policies and meritocracy.
Government is the driving force of reform and reconstruction, which must begin its task with utmost honesty. Falsehood at every level must be avoided. Consider spurious, unsubstantiated, in simple language, false lawsuits. How is it compatible with the rule of just law? Is it compatible with honesty? Falsehood and honesty do not go together.
Take pragmatism. How can you be pragmatic if you are busy glorifying some and vilifying others? Pragmatic approach calls for level-headed thinking -- choose technocrats, bureaucrats, and functionaries based on efficiency, not loyalty or grievances of past deprivation.
And what about meritocracy? Starting an administration based on quotas is the opposite of the idea of meritocracy. Get the best person available to do the job whatever that job may be.
States are necessary evils. People need states because without which they become helpless and vulnerable and when they have one, they feel oppressed and seek to choose Albert Hirschman’s alternatives: Exit, voice, loyalty. People’s voices must be heard but the genuine voices often remain muted in the face of the much louder voices of loyalists. Or honest ones choose the exit option as they want to keep a safe distance from dishonesty and falsehood.
Habibul Haque Khondker is a sociologist and columnist.