After everything that’s happened

Between July 19 and August 3, the agitating quota reform activists have been given offers of dialogue twice from the highest level of the government. In the first instance, the quota movement student leaders had an audience with three government ministers at a state guest house at an ungodly hour -- around 2am -- to be precise on July 20. The ministers were mandated by the prime minister to have talks with the quota movement students’ body’s coordinators. The coordinators made it crystal clear then that they had handed over the ministers an 8-point charter of demands and a dialogue between the two sides could only take place provided the government paid heed to their demands.  

Three coordinators of the platform met two ministers and a state minister at the state guest house Padma and placed eight-point demands, which include, among others, probe into all the killings took place during the recent students’ protests, arrests of the perpetrators, actions against government functionaries accused of instigating ruling party’s student to attack on peaceful movement of quota protesters, withdrawal of all cases filed against students who participated in the movement etc. 

And the second dialogue offer came yesterday in the form of the premier’s call that all doors to her official residence are open for the quota protesters to sit for talks. She also mandated a number of her party leaders (not ministers this time) to have talks with the quota protest coordinators, which the protesting student leaders rejected outright.

Now, we need to understand what prompted such outright rejection. It’s easy from the government’s standpoint to see its political opponents’ hands here but a reality check will help us understand that there are definitely more into it -- a deep sense of deceit, dejection, and mistrust.

The most unfortunate and unlawful thing that happened in between two dialogue offers from the government is -- keeping six of the key protest coordinators hostage

While the appellate division has done its part by giving a quota reform directive, prompting the government to issue gazette keeping 7 percent quota in government service recruitments, the government did almost nothing, other than lip service, to address the other concerns of the protestors laid out in their 8-point demand. 

Instead, some of the ruling party fronts’ cadres continued attacking on protesting students in many places in Dhaka and elsewhere in the country, and under the government’s behest its law enforcing apparatus went on a manhunt arresting over 11,000 people over the past two weeks -- that includes around a hundred HSC examinees and dozens of other students -- throwing their academic future in uncertainty. Each day parents line up before courts’ premises all over the country with the hope that they can have a glimpse of their wards brought in by prison vans and also seeking justice for their immediate bails and release. 

The most unfortunate and unlawful thing that happened in between two dialogue offers from the government is -- keeping six of the key protest coordinators hostage by the sleuths at the Detective Branch headquarters in the name of providing them “safety.” During a six-day hostage situation, they were unlawfully forced to make a video message announcing withdrawal of the movement programme.

When some of them were still reeling in pain and undergoing treatments at a city hospital, they were picked up against their free will and were forced to stay at the DB headquarters. They are also alleged of forcing them to meet high state functionaries and pronounce the movement over. During the last two days prior to their release from that captivity they kept fasting in protest of forces being applied on them. All along the home minister and now transferred DB head kept on claiming that the six coordinators delivered the movement withdrawal video message of their own. 

So far, no head rolled for instigating party vigilante forces against what appeared initially a peaceful students’ demonstration and no head rolled for forceful confinement of the quota protest coordinators, and for recording that video message under duress. After all these bloodletting, excessive use of force and heavy handedness, the protesting students are feeling completely deceived and lost faith in the government. Now all these talk offers appear too little, too late.

Reaz Ahmad is Executive Editor, Dhaka Tribune.