Now that the country has returned to a state of relative calm after witnessing brutal use of force to quash a peaceful student movement, the last thing any citizen would like to see is any more heavy-handedness by the state apparatus. But the way law enforcement agencies have embarked into (what appeared to be) a wholesale arrest frenzy, thousands of people across the country are finding themselves in some of the most overcrowded jails.
Any sane mind would wonder how such wholesale incarceration is going to help dispensation of justice after Bangladesh had just witnessed tragic ends of so many young lives -- most allegedly from injuries caused by shotgun pellets. While official death figures are yet to come through, unofficially over 200 people have died in the violence that flared in Dhaka and elsewhere in the country from July 16 to 21. The lost lives include those of young students, members of law enforcement, journalists, and many other general members of the public.
People in general expect to get normalcy back to their life, sooner than later, and expect the government to shift gears, come to senses, stop the use of excessive force, and initiate dialogue and reconciliation instead. They expect the least a responsive government can offer to its citizenry now is no further “acts of vengeance” or “retaliation,” and do everything under its disposal to pacify the situation and work towards confidence building.
But, in the name of chasing the culprits who have vandalized different state properties during the six-day mayhem, the government apparatus can’t just go on an arrest frenzy. It doesn’t help, and didn’t help in the past too. Haven’t we seen enough of such wholesale arrests of people after the so-called Hefazat movement in 2013 and also after student movements as recent as in 2018?
After weeks, most of the arrested people got released on bail while many cases involving thousands of people as accused have yet to be disposed of. Take Hefazat cases for one example. A total of 83 cases were filed over the incidents in May 2013, but after 11 years, police could submit charge sheets in only 21 of those cases and submit final probe reports in two, keeping probe into the remaining 60 cases in abeyance.
If media reports are something to go by, the country’s law enforcement agencies have arrested nearly 7,000 people this week in pursuit of thousands of people (mostly unnamed) who have been shown accused in several hundred cases filed over the July 16-21 violent incidents. These numbers are adding up to an already overcrowded prison population in Bangladesh.
The country’s 68 jails are housing inmates twice their capacity, thereby depriving the inmates some of the most basic rights and privileges in jails. According to a 2021 report by the World Prison Brief (WPB), eight out of every 10 prisoners in Bangladesh are in jail either as pre-trial detainees or on remand, making the country one of the top three countries of the world with the highest proportion of detainees.
Concerns are there about how diligently these lawful courses are being followed when people in their hundreds are being arrested on a daily basis
Now the more intriguing question is whether due process of law is being followed when such large-scale arrests are being made in such a short period of time nationwide. If one takes the testimonies of hundreds of people who line up each morning in court premises to trace whether their near and dear ones, who suddenly went missing, are there in the prison vans -- one would easily understand how much pain the people are enduring. Many of them alleged that they had no clues that their friends and family members were picked up by the members of the law enforcement agencies.
We need to remind ourselves of the set of directives that the Appellate Division gave in a judgement in May 2016 regarding law enforcers’ standard protocols in cases of arrest and detention of people. It says, law enforcers making arrests of any person should prepare a memorandum of arrest immediately after the arrest and obtain the signature of the arrestee with the date and time of arrest in the said memorandum. It further states, any member of a law enforcement force who makes an arrest must inform it to a nearest relative of the arrestee and in the absence of his relative, to a friend to be suggested by the arrestee, as soon as practicable but not later than 12 hours.
Due process requires an entry be made in the diary as to the ground of arrest and name of the person who informed the law enforcing officer to arrest the person or made the complaint along with his address. It requires the law enforcers to disclose their identities and if demanded, show their identity cards to the person arrested and to the persons present at the time of arrest. Our Appellate Division has outlined very well all necessary guidelines that the law enforcement agencies must follow.
Now concerns are there about how diligently these lawful courses are being followed when people in their hundreds are being arrested on a daily basis. It’s a capacity issue too for our law enforcement agencies. And for those who are getting detained -- it’s of course a serious rights issue that the state and state apparatus can’t ignore.
Reaz Ahmad is Executive Editor, Dhaka Tribune.