THE LAST WORD

On livability and choice

Dhaka is, apparently, 168th out of 173 on a global list of liveable cities. As this is one of those lists where a smaller number is better -- it’s not so great a place to live then. This poses a certain problem because 10 million people choose to live there -- or perhaps choose not to live somewhere else. Which suggests this idea that Dhaka is some hellhole from which all desire, or should desire, to escape. 

 

Sure, it's possible to do so but calling 10 million people idiots because of how they live their lives is one of those things that's somewhat dangerous. It's rather more likely that the one single one making the comment has the intelligence problem. 

 

One answer to this would be that the ranking comes from a unit of The Economist. As I once tried out working for them and didn't get hired then that's all we need -- pfft, what do they know? A slightly more responsible comment might be that they're judging by the standards of a comfortable rich world and bourgeois lifestyle -- which they are. But the real and correct comment would be one of the grand lessons of economics.

 

“There are no solutions, only trade-offs.” This particularly pithy version comes from Thomas Sowell, but it really is one of those grand truths. We cannot do everything, it is only possible to do some subset of everything. 

 

So which? That means trading off this for that -- we cannot do it all. Another name for this is “opportunity costs” and that's usually used as the second lesson of economics (the first is “incentives matter”). Note that this is all long before we start to talk about Marx, or free markets, or capitalism and all the rest. The universe doesn't allow everything to be done -- so, we must make decisions about which will be.

 

So, we've 10 million people voluntarily living in the city that's the 168th on the list of 173 places to live. Why are they doing that? Which means that we've got to not just look at the downsides of living in Dhaka, we've got to look at the upsides. 

 

Obviously, there are some restrictions. Given passports and visas it's not allowed that everyone moves to London, or Paris. But even so, why do so many crowd into this city rather than being more spread out across the country? 

 

One economic answer is “agglomeration” which is a fancy word for where there are more people there are more opportunities. This is why cities have been richer than rural areas throughout human history. We can also be a little less comfortable with this idea and point out that the bureaucrats and the politicians are all in Dhaka because that's where the jobs and our money are. There could even be a merit in moving the government capital to somewhere else -- the cynic might suggest Teknaf so they're a nice long distance from the rest of us.

 

But the real answer is that, despite the crowding, the pollution, the costs, Dhaka is a better place to make a living than much of the rest of Bangladesh. Even after those costs, the living is better. Which is the thing that needs to change if we are to relieve the pressure on the number of people trying to live in Dhaka. 

 

Now, no one's ever really cracked this. My native Britain was the first country to industrialize and London still has as outsized an influence on the nation as Dhaka does upon Bangladesh. Just getting rich doesn't do it. Alternative centres of power, or politics, finance, industry, all in different places (Germany or the US are examples) might.

 

But even that's not quite right, as that's to insist upon some plan for society rather than society being the outcome of what people prefer to do. Which is where I think the correct answer lies. Everywhere should be free to do as they wish. So too should the people. If that ends up with one urban megapolis in the country so be it -- that's what's been chosen by the people. 

 

And, you know, if that's what the people want then why shouldn't the people have it?

 

Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.