The UN, the West, and a reckless Israel

The United Nations Security Council long ago outlived its usefulness. There has been a built-in mechanism guaranteeing its feebleness. When the world body was founded in 1945, the point about five permanent UNSC members possessing the power to veto any decision reached by the council ensured the non-functional nature of it.

Over the decades the UN has had a massive expansion through the entry of an increasing number of new members. Where the Security Council initially comprised 10 members, including the five permanent members, it now has 15 members. The number of permanent members has remained the same. Despite demands made down the years for an expansion in the number of permanent Security Council members, to include such states as Brazil, India and Japan, nothing has happened.

The UNSC is today remarkable for what it does not do or is not permitted to do. It has turned into a talking shop where members trade accusations, where resolutions are adopted and then swiftly shot down by any one of the permanent members. Worse, the Security Council has become hostage to permanent members which make no secret of the preferences they have for countries that might be compelled to ask it for a redress of grievances.

And then there is the hypocrisy of it all. Sunday’s UNSC debate on Iran’s drone and missile attacks on Israel are a clear pointer to the enervated nature of the Security Council. The American deputy ambassador’s speech was an outright condemnation of Iran which demanded an unequivocal response from the UNSC to Tehran’s action. Nowhere did Robert Wood, the US delegate, mention the violation of the UN Charter and the Vienna Convention by Israel when Netanyahu’s government blew up the Iranian consulate in Damascus.

The American statement was a patent insight into the collapse of diplomacy in the West. It was a reflection of the speed with which Israel’s friends in the West have forsaken diplomacy in favour of destructive partisanship at the global level. None of these states -- the United States, Britain, France and others -- thought it necessary to condemn Israel for its violation of Iran’s diplomatic status in Damascus as well as the targeted assassinations of Iranian military officers and scientists over the past few years. In recent times, these nations have focused on the Hamas atrocities committed on October 7 last year but have shown scant concern over the murder of nearly 40,000 Palestinians by Israel in Gaza.

The Iranian assault on Israel was quick to raise hackles among western leaders. Joe Biden reiterated his country’s iron-clad guarantees of ensuring Israel’s security. British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak called Iran’s action reckless. Much a similar position was adopted in other western capitals, giving one the clear impression that the West was not acknowledging the truth underlying the situation. Genocide is being committed by Israel in Gaza; illegal Israeli settlers have been committing atrocities against Arabs in occupied Arab land; and Israel has been actively involved in belligerent military activities in Lebanon and Syria.

None of this was made mention of by Robert Wood or his western allies at the UNSC on Sunday. But there certainly were moments when the Russian ambassador and his Iranian counterpart spoke the truth. The Russian condemnation of western hypocrisy made sense, but of course it did not embarrass the West. Diplomacy in western capitals has come to a pass where embarrassment has gone missing.

The tragedy of Ukraine is a case in point. Nato ought not to have crept close to the Russian frontier, but it did, precipitating a crisis an end to which is not yet in sight. It has been collective folly on the part of the West to present Volodymyr Zelensky as the man to promote democratic values. Vladimir Putin has not lost to Zelensky and will likely win the war. It was folly to suppose that Russia would be defeated through an infusion of Nato weapons into Kyiv and western warnings of doom for Moscow.

In the Middle East today, the picture is obvious: Were it not for western military support -- think of the role played by US and British forces in shooting down Iran’s drones as they made their way to Israel -- for Tel Aviv, Netanyahu’s state would not have the ability or capacity to defend itself on its own. Israel’s defence lies in Washington, London, Paris and Berlin. That is the unvarnished truth. And yet when Gilad Erdan speaks at the UNSC on the Iranian attack, he ignores such truths.

Erdan’s statement at the UNSC on Thursday was a rant. For a man who had some months ago demanded the resignation of Secretary General Antonio Guterres, such behaviour was quite natural. He spoke, improbably, of Iran’s goal of global domination. How a diplomat could arrive at such a conclusion is mind-boggling. He referred to the genocide committed by the Nazis with no reference to the genocide being committed by Israel in Gaza. In language steeped in ignorance, he compared Ayatollah Ali Khamenei to Adolf Hitler, placing the Fuhrer’s Germany and the Islamic Republic of Iran at the same level. With such diplomats, be they from any country, it is not hard to understand why geopolitics is today conspicuous by its absence.

The issues faced by the world today are two-pronged. On the one hand, the western powers, by their refusal to put the leash on Israel and by condemning the wrong country over the destruction of the Iranian consulate in Syria, are fast losing credibility before the rest of the world. As a matter of fact, the men who lead in western capitals have already had their credibility eroded. They are men who are not to be trusted any more by people both in their countries and elsewhere.

On the other hand, Israel is today a byword for reckless behaviour in the world. As long as it is not disciplined, as long as its genocide in Gaza is allowed to go on, as long as it goes on producing state-sponsored assassins to murder foreign politicians, generals and scientists, as long as it occupies Arab land and encourages its citizens to build illegal settlements there, the world will not find its way back to sanity and a modicum of peace.

One final point: The United Nations has dwindled into a body which has lost its sense of purpose. Not even the humblest individual in any part of the world takes it seriously. That is a shame.

Syed Badrul Ahsan is Consultant Editor, Dhaka Tribune.