Demanding an apology for 1971 war crimes is our valid right as Bangladeshis, but a tendency to demonise everything from Pakistan suggests immaturity.
Although four decades have passed since Bangladesh became independent, there seems to be a section of society including famous cricket players who were born long after the liberation war, which has decided to abhor everything from Pakistan.
The atrocities committed by the Pakistani forces in 1971 can never be forgotten, but is it not somewhat outdated for Bangladeshis to harbour a visceral antipathy towards an entire nation?
Shahid Afridi, the Pakistani cricketer recently came to Bangladesh to open a boutique. Mehjabeen, a local model who paraded the stage wearing the shop’s dresses, came under flak from a wide range of bloggers for showcasing attire from Pakistan. Some even reprimanded her for simply enjoying her stage moments with the cricketer.
Surely, this is taking animosity a tad too far, as a little added excitement because the promoter is a famous cricketer was perfectly natural.
It is one thing to denounce the administration which engineered the massacre of innocent people in the then East-Pakistan, but targeting everything to do with Pakistan now appears more like paranoia.
It is always wrong to generalise about an entire group of people; just because Israel is run by Jews and the state oppresses Palestinians, it does not mean all Jews can or should be criticised for Israel’s actions.
Such criticisms of this fashion show were also out of step with the popularity of dresses made in Pakistan during the wedding season in Bangladesh, not to mention the support given by some Bangladeshis whenever the Pakistan cricket team takes the field.
Let me be very clear – the genocide perpetrated by the invading army in 1971 was a grave violation of human rights, but for generations born years after the war to stereotype all Pakistanis as mortal enemies is more the product of an irrational rage.
It was wrong for the Bangladeshi model to be criticised for simply showcasing some clothes and acting perfectly within her professional work ethic.
Just to give this matter more context, during the second world war, Germany invaded and committed atrocities across most of Europe. Yet, as part of the European Union, former enemy nations now have open borders and form a shared economic zone.
Despite many signs of tension within the EU, no one wants the positive aspects of this model to fall apart. Similarly, while India has fought three major wars with Pakistan and relations have always been strained, this has not stopped Pakistanis religiously watching Bollywood movies or Pakistani cricket players being swooned over in India.
Current US-Vietnam ties are a good illustration of how past mistakes cannot be used to define current relationships. Once bitter enemies who fought a protracted and bloody war, the US today supplies Vietnam’s highest number of tourists and battlegrounds have become popular tourist spots. The message here is clear – follies of the past should not be used to define present day engagements, especially at the social level.
By lambasting Mehjabeen, a lot of people have revealed more about their own insular self image and outlook, than anything she has done. Maybe the reason behind their outbursts was motivated more by jealousy than concern about the emotive issues of 1971?
No one is asking us to forget Bangladesh’s glorious independence movement, but the world has seen many ideological shifts since then.
While, China, Pakistan’s ally in 1971, was among the last nations to recognise Bangladesh (8 October, 1975), China is today our staunchest friend and supplier of much of our military hardware. Saudi Arabia, which also only recognised Bangladesh in 1975, believing for a long time that the dismemberment of a Muslim state was wrong, provides a lot of support and employment to Bangladeshis today.
Meanwhile, the US had its navy’s seventh fleet on standby in the Bay of Bengal to aid the Pakistan army in 1971 and only went on the back-foot after the Soviet Union issued an ultimatum saying that if the US intervened, it would act as well.
Though the US has never apologised formally for taking the wrong side, Bangladesh has always tried to maintain friendly relations and never shied away from seeking US aid. As for many peoples’ perennial US-visa/green card obsession, well that is common in other countries also!
Bangladesh’s relationship with the UK provides possibly the most potent example of long term reconciliation or at least acceptance of former foes by Bangladeshis. History books are filled with criticisms of the British colonial period which saw all Bengal ruled with an iron hand and independence movements suppressed without mercy.
Yet for all our nationalism, despite the 150 years of imperial rule, Bangladeshis are infatuated with the British; whenever their ministers visit, red carpets are rolled out, police protection clears roads and anything they say or suggest makes the headlines.
Of course post WW2 Britain has shed (or perhaps was forced by circumstances to discard!) the imperial legacy of domination, and this is partly why Bangladeshis are happy to accept its new considerate image.
But why then do we keep invoking bloodthirsty images of 1971 onto any modern day incarnation of Pakistan? Especially given that in 1974, less than three years after liberation, the leader of newly liberated Bangladesh, Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, went to Pakistan himself to attend the OIC Summit.
Whatever the inner turmoil he and the Bangladeshis accompanying him might have felt, they went ahead and attended the summit as representatives of an independent sovereign nation.
By the way, Bangladesh recently gave awards to 13 Pakistanis for their bold role against West Pakistani government actions during 1971, which clearly shows why any 1971 related indignation must not be directed at Pakistani people generally but at its brutal leaders during the Bangladesh liberation war.
As for our unswerving demand for an unconditional apology, many Pakistanis have come to realise its importance. Not too long ago, Pakistani journalist Hamid Mir said in an interview, “the time is coming very soon when the Pakistan parliament will demand that the government make a public apology to the people of Bangladesh.”
When a media figures makes such an observation openly, this shows mindsets are being transformed. Therefore, let us not sour relations when signs of change are in the air!