DEEP DIVE

A tale of two justices

I want to begin with the trial of Socrates in 399 BCE in Athens. Socrates, the philosopher, and a public intellectual in the modern-day sense, faced accusations of corrupting the minds of Athens' youth and questioning its religion.

If you are a philosopher true to your name and not just an armchair one, you are bound to utter things displeasing to the powers that be.

In Plato’s writings, we learn that one of Socrates’ students and friends, Crito, appeared in his prison cell, pleading with him to escape. Despite the arrangements made by the wealthy Crito, Socrates not only refused to flee but also persuaded Crito (and all of us) that he couldn't evade the law.

Socrates argued that a citizen must show utmost respect for the institution of law. Crito even arranged for Socrates to settle in another city-state. Socrates contended that the laws of Athens legalized his parents' marriage, legitimized his birth, and so forth.

Using a contemporary term, Socrates employed the argument of legal positivism, asserting that laws, as written, must be mechanically followed.

Contrarily, the rival perspective of natural laws suggests considering the bigger picture, including morality, public good, and, I would add, common sense.

From a legal positivism viewpoint, the punishment of Socrates, condemned to drink hemlock to end his life, was justified. He faced a trial by a jury of fellow Athenians.

However, in the broader perspective of the spirit of justice, from the standpoint of natural law, or simply common sense, one can question the merit of the case, arguing that philosophers' role is to pose critical questions.

From my standpoint, Socrates was wrongfully accused, duly tried according to Athenian law, found guilty, and sentenced to death. And, of course, Socrates complied.

Justice in the broader and more durable sense of the term, refers to fairness, morality, and equity in various aspects of life. Philosopher John Rawls defined justice as “fairness.”

Legal experts of justice, such as HLA Hart stressed the importance of considerations of morality and not instrumental application of law in the vein of legal positivism.

The judicial system is designed to weigh the merit of the case as per laws of the country, to take circumstances into consideration and among other things the intent of the person accused of wrongdoing.

From a common sense point of view, we make a distinction between the letters of the law and the spirit of the law. The spirit of the law captures the idea of the moral basis of law.

From a common sense point of view, it did not make sense to me when I saw court cases were lodged against a newspaper editor or a journalist in multiple courts across the country. I wondered whether judges in a remote district could have said that this case is already being judged in another court in another city so I would not accept this case, moreover, I have many back-logged cases that demand my attention.

If the law forces the concerned editor to appear in multiple places for the same case, this is a clear case of weaponization of the law. And this is dangerous. Laws are supposed to protect public good and must not be used to harass people.

Justice as such encompasses a wide moral and ethical compass. Legal justice, on the other hand, is only confined to the rules and regulations set by the legal system of the specific country.

Suppose when you put a person on trial for a technical breach of the law using the implied principle of legal positivism without taking the larger context into account which includes, among others, the intent of the person accused, and the overall character of the person accused.

What kind of person is standing in the dock? All his life, was he not doing things to benefit the larger society? Didn’t he help the poorest of the poor? Did his innovative programs help change the lives of the women paving their emancipation? Which side is he on? For the rich, or for the poor? Did he enhance the image of his country to the rest of the world? Didn’t he get the only Nobel prize that added a precious feather in the crown of the nation? Wasn’t his model replicated in many parts of the world? Did his ideas help the poor break the cycle of poverty in other parts of the world?

Does sentencing him serve any public good, or enhance the country’s image in the global community? Why are a large number of public intellectuals, Nobel laureates, and statesmen vouching for him?

Yes, I am reflecting on the case involving Professor Yunus. And I am reflecting it from a purely common sense point of view, not a legal point of view.  

There are instances in history when laws undermined justice. Think of Apartheid laws. Those were laws in a technical sense justified by the South African government, but the majority of the people in South Africa as well as the world viewed them as immoral. 

Justice must take the broader picture into consideration that includes morality as well as public good.

Habibul Haque Khondker is a sociology professor at Zayed University, Abu Dhabi who previously taught at the National University of Singapore.