“Half of the American people have never read a newspaper,” said Gore Vidal, who called his countrymen’s lack of education “the joke of the world.” Considering this, it seems excusable that Lauren Green didn’t know Muslims were allowed to write about Jesus.
The Internet, with its typical penchant for hyperbole, is calling Green’s recent interview with Reza Aslan the most embarrassing interview [the US television station] Fox News has ever done. Aslan, a fantastically poetic and articulate scholar of religion, seemed surprised when Green asked him about his motivations for writing about Jesus.
But I’m surprised he was surprised. Don’t we expect this from Fox News? Didn’t we already have them pegged as the most happily uneducated, controversy-hungry “news” network out there?
Despite Fox News’s tireless mission to bring ignorance to the ignorant, most Americans don’t get educated anyway about Islam or religion, generally. So we can’t really expect them to know the answer to the question Green asked.
Truth is, it’s a reasonable question. I have often wondered why an American would dedicate decades to studying Italian art, or why a Christian would spend his life becoming an expert on Islam. What’s their motivation?
That’s the question Green asked Aslan: “You're a Muslim, so why did you write a book about the founder of Christianity?” What’s perhaps embarrassing about the whole affair is that he didn’t really answer the question. Rather, he told Green that he had a right to write about Jesus because he’d graduated from university.
There’s a certain dignity in refusing to be offended by offensive people. There is only one way to strive for civility and reason, to paraphrase Vaclav Havel, and that is civilly and reasonably. There was an opportunity missed in Aslan’s interview to educate the public about why a Muslim would be interested in Christianity, and thereby, about a possible reason for pluralist dialogue.
Jesus was a man admired in his time and for all times afterwards, especially by Christians and Muslims, both of whom love him for his goodness and revere him for being a prophet of love and salvation.
That’s an answer that gives any human, PhD-holder or not, the right to write about Jesus, or whatever else he or she chooses. It’s an answer that opens the door to a conversation about coming together with a person of a different faith, based on the idea that you can admire a person regardless of their religion. It’s the sort of answer that inspires us to be more interested in our neighbours and makes us want to get to know each other better. And yes, to know about what motivates us.