It is only apt that a person named Snowden should be the cause for freezing relations between the world’s two top nuclear powers. The scene aired across the globe, showing a stolid-faced Putin alongside a rather resigned Obama, says it all – Russia is not for bending.
The US president looked helpless at times because it is not every day that the head of a major state shows this type of steely resolve to disregard American authority in full view of the international media.
The much talked about security contractor Edward Snowden may be at the heart of all this but perhaps his whistleblowing is just a small factor.
This writer sees the furore created by Russia’s granting of asylum to Snowden as the perfect situation Russia had sought to prove to the world, that whilst the Soviet Union may have crumbled long ago, Russia alone can stand as a potent balancing factor.
Putin’s Russia has been defying western positions on international affairs for quite some time now, particularly in Syria.
More active Western military intervention may have taken place in Syria long ago, had not China and Russia maintained their veto stance.
In fact, it is only now that the actual situation in Syria is becoming clear. Sectarian Shia-Sunni divisions lie at the heart of the violent conflict as much as the call for a change to the leadership by the masses, inspired by toppling of autocrats in other Arab states.
To be very honest, if the US and the British decide to help the rebels in Syria they will also be aiding some religious radicals who have sided with the anti-Assad forces.
While the death of civilians has been truly appalling, Syria has now turned into a conundrum of sorts.
Coming back to recent strained US-Russia relations, someone needs to raise this question – what would have happened if Snowden had been a Russian seeking sanctuary in the US?
Common sense suggests that in such a scenario, Russia would be ferociously denounced as a violator of democratic rights and freedom of speech and the whistleblower might be given permission to stay in the US.
The US defence’s line – by exposing surveillance programmes, Snowden has jeopardised anti-terror strategies – is flimsy and downright silly. The former NSA contractor’s action prove one thing, that the US spies indiscriminately.
Excuses about containing potential terror threats only masquerade an irrepressible American desire to know what others are doing! Snowden’s revelations also show that the British listened in on their European counterparts. They surely did not expect fellow EU and Nato partners to be colluding with al Qaida?
Whatever the case, it is perhaps no bad thing that Russia and the US are poles apart if one takes into consideration the implications for geopolitics.
It is not always that one superpower always takes the correct approach so a global balance of power is important. The observation can be made that the world does not need a post-Soviet era Russia enfeebled by corruption, lack of leadership and stagnation.
Using Syria and Snowden, Russia has sent an unequivocal message. She is not going to play along with the tunes of others.
Thus Mr Snowden has found a place, albeit temporary, in Russia, and whistleblowing has not left him stuck with life in the transit lounge.
Perhaps there is a lesson here if we shift to Bangladesh, where there have not been any emulations of Snowden yet. But we need some whistleblowers too.
The question is who will grant safety to such people? Most importantly, there is no guarantee that such a person would not regrettably die in an “encounter.”
Here is a hypothetical situation. Let us imagine someone privy to illegitimate events within the government decides to spill the beans and then seeks refuge with the Americans or the British. Would (or could) the respective countries offer help?
This may be a valid debate because today or tomorrow there will be someone whose moral sense will overpower his/her impulses to remain quiet and go with the flow.
As some of us wait for such a day, let us try to understand that tension between the US and Russia is not necessarily harmful.
The history of human civilisation suggests top powers must never be too intimate. Snowden has been but a catalyst ensuring power divisions. Without such people or factors, efforts for US world domination would be pedestrian.