Wages are set by every other employer

The RMG workers' union wants a minimum wage of Tk20-22,000, with an absolute minimum of not less than Tk18,000. Well, that's nice. Now, shall we explain the facts of economic life to them?  

One reaction to what follows is that, given that I am a foreign neoliberal, of course I would say all of this. I've even done some paid work for the BGMEA some years ago -- clearly I’m just bought and paid for. But the problem with that dismissal of what I'm about to say is that whatever me, my, or my wallet attributes these two things are true.

Firstly, wages are not set by industry. Workers, labour, can move between industries. Change jobs that is. So, wages are, in fact, set not by the employer, but by every other employer. What determines someones' wages is what they could get in another job, not what they're being offered in this one.

This is why a bus driver in Sweden (as Ha Joon Chang, an economist working on these matters, says) gets more than one in Bangladesh. Even a Bangladeshi immigrant to Sweden who becomes a bus driver there will earn more than one in Dhaka (and wouldn't we all pay to see the video of that, Dhaka bus driving style in Stockholm?). Because wages in Sweden just are generally higher, therefore an employer has to pay labour more to get exactly the same job done.

Wages are not determined by the profitability of a company, or even a sector. They're determined by what's the other next best job that workers can get. Or as another economist, Paul Krugman, puts it, “wages are determined in a national labour market.” What determines what RMG workers are paid is the price that rickshaw drivers, cooks, cha-wallahs, and housewives can get.  

Yes, yes, it's true that the skills don't translate over exactly and all that. It is still entirely and wholly true that the wages in the clothes factories are determined not by employers, but by what workers could get elsewhere. Think about it for a moment. Put one of those factories in England, where a teenager can get Tk200,000 a month working in a McDonalds. What would wages have to be to get people to work in the RMG factory? Quite, wages are determined by what the worker can get elsewhere. 

The second is this idea of “the cost of living.” The union is saying that in order to be able to live, the workers should get this much. But that's not actually correct. What they mean is “this is how much it costs to have the standard of living we think is right.” Well, great, you hope for that standard of living. But that isn't “the cost of living.” It's “the cost of the lifestyle we desire.” Which are two very different things.  

At which point you can just dismiss me as one of those neoliberals on the side of the capitalist oppressors if you wish. But that's to gain only half of the argument -- now comes the liberal part. Yes, of course we want RMG workers -- in fact everyone -- to have a better lifestyle. I think a useful goal for us all is that everyone should have an income as good as mine. Somewhere toward the top of the 10% of the incomes in the world -- as above, that's by accident of birth in an already rich nation, like the Swedish bus driver, not some inherent virtue of mine. Pure luck of birth, no more.

So, how do we get there? Well, listening to Krugman again: "what would happen if people who work for such low wages manage to achieve Western productivity?" The economist's answer is, "if they achieve Western productivity, they will be paid Western wages." But note that this is combined with that national labour market part. It is if all Bangladeshis are as productive as all Americans that all Bangladeshis will then get American wages. This means that economic growth, that increase in GDP, that scouring out of the economy of Bangladesh, those inefficient, unproductive, uses of labour that prevent this.

This really will seem perverse to non-economists, but I do assure you that it is true. Replace rickshaws with taxis, 1 hectare farms with large ones, generally industrialize the economy, then wages will rise. Not just for the taxi drivers, or the now richer farmers, but for everyone. Including the RMG workers.  

Because what limits wages in the clothing factories is not how much the owners are willing to pay. It's how much do they have to pay to tempt the workers into the factories. So, make other jobs better paid. Economic development that is. 

Or as Karl Marx put it -- stripped of his difficult language. Capitalists compete for the labour they can employ. So, more capitalists, more competition, the higher wages will be.