Lull before the storm?

Ramadan is a period of reflection, compassion and moderation for Muslims. In Bangladesh, the holy month of fasting brings a welcome respite from zero-sum political confrontation that characterises our dysfunctional democracy for the rest of the year. It has been a norm for our political parties to shun violence during this month, and thankfully so. Notwithstanding unholy hartals (strikes) by Jamaat in the holy month, the political scene has remained peaceful by and large.

During Ramadan, street confrontation makes way for iftar (fast-breaking) politics. Iftar parties typically become a show of political solidarity, while both sides of the political divide at least exchange mutual invitations in a rare spirit of bonhomie. Whether the relative calm is due to the spiritual quest for restraint or lack of appetite for violence (pun intended) during the fasting period, there is a temporal sense of relief amongst the people that brickbats and bullets have been replaced by piajus (lentil fritters) and haleem (curry stew).

As we approach the last two weeks of Ramadan, we cannot help wonder what is in store for us politically post-Eid. Is this the lull before the storm? Less than six months ahead of the general election, the Awami League (AL) and Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP) have failed to resolve the political impasse over the modalities of the election-time administration. The growing uncertainty over the next general election does not augur well for democracy, while the absence of a bipartisan consensus makes the spectre of violence more likely than ever.

So what is the sticking point in the election deadlock? The ongoing stalemate is over the AL being adamant about holding general elections under an elected administration as per existing constitutional provisions, while the BNP remains unwavering in its demand to restore the non-party caretaker government. This is déjà vu with the tables turned as the AL was campaigning for a caretaker government, while the BNP was rejecting it as unconstitutional pre-1996. In the present scenario, the respective positions of both parties may appear to be irreconcilable on the surface but there is still room for compromise without either side losing face.

To be fair, both parties have been less inflexible than it seems. The AL announced it will consider an “all-party” interim administration within the constitution, while the BNP has made known it will consider a “non-partisan” election-time administration without the caretaker terminology. There can be several creative solutions to end the political impasse by accommodating the stances of both parties, including an “all-party” interim administration led by a “non-partisan” head elected through existing constitutional provisions, such as vacating a parliamentary seat. Other variants could be a “non-partisan” technocrat government under the prime minister (PM) or an alternate majority party leader who is acceptable to both sides.

Other options can be explored through open dialogue between both political parties to resolve the election deadlock without pre-conditions on either side. The post-election reactions by the minority party in the previous general elections of 1991, 1996, 2001 and 2008 indicate that neither AL nor BNP found the erstwhile caretaker government an infallible mechanism for free, fair and credible elections. The previous model was also disastrous for politicisation of the civil society and judiciary. In this backdrop, the current impasse offers an opportunity for the AL and BNP to come together with an imaginative solution for a constitutionally-mandated election-time government through meaningful dialogue that addresses the concerns of both sides.

Unfortunately, AL and BNP have taken one step forward and two steps backwards when it comes to the question of a dialogue. In recent months, both sides have backtracked from their conciliatory stances preferring counter-productive ultimatums and preconditions instead. The ongoing impasse raises the question as to whether the dysfunctional relationship between both parties is a calculated strategy to keep the country divided and distracted from asking for better governance and accountability. Six months ahead of the general election, it is disconcerting to see very little discussion on policy issues while both sides are engaged in mutual acrimony.

A consensus on election-time government will require the highest level of political will, sincerity and commitment. However, time is running out. The PM has announced that October 25 will be the last day of the Parliament, implying any negotiated solution as per existing constitutional provisions will require a consensus within the next thirteen weeks. Given Ramadan followed by Eid-ul-Fitr and Eid-ul-Azha holdiays, the opening for a possible compromise would be further narrowed down to eight weeks between mid-August to mid-October. A consensus needs to be reached within this short time frame to ensure the participation of all major parties in the general elections to ensure its credibility.

Can the AL and BNP rise to the occasion? This is a million dollar question, figuratively and literally, as the fate of our nation is dependent on it. We need to resolve the political impasse immediately to ensure political stability. The AL and BNP should reach a compromise in the interest of the nation, coming out of the polarising influence of fringe leftist and rightist factions respectively, pushing both parties apart.  There is also no alternative to resolve the political impasse to prevent radical groups like Hefazat-e-Islam trying to take advantage of the schism between the AL and BNP. The recent emergence of such extremist groups can only be countered if there is political harmony between both parties. In this respect, a compromise on the election-time government can also pave the way for consensus on other national issues.

The election deadlock must be resolved for political stability and the nation to move forward. Both parties need to rise to the occasion to remain relevant in the democratic process. Let us not forget that the general election is not an end itself, but means to an end.