In 1971: A People’s History from Bangladesh, Pakistan and India, Zakaria, a Pakistani oral historian, juxtaposes the state narratives around the events of 1971 against the lived experiences of a range of individuals, including some of the same individuals that Tripathi interviewed. In addition, she had also met others from both the erstwhile wings of Pakistan, civilians and military men (and their wives). What emerges from her telling is a nuanced story that is poignantly sympathetic to the survivors of the War, without losing the complexities involved.
Moving from oral history, better use could be made of archival materials from Pakistan and Bangladesh. Much of the official archival records from Pakistan might not be forthcoming in near future, and there might not be much by way of the Bangladeshi official archives. There is, however, enough material that can be analyzed using various social studies methods.
Tazeen Murshid’s The Sacred and the Secular: Bengal Muslim discourses, 1871-1977 is perhaps the most comprehensive narrative of the intellectual, social, cultural, and political evolution that emerged over the course of the century to the 1970s. One striking feature of the Columbia academic’s book is that unlike anyone else of her ideological tradition -- the same that Tripathi relies on -- she claims no inevitable march of history to the glory days of the early 1970s. In fact, her story ends in 1977, not only after the birth of Bangladesh, but also the setbacks suffered by secularism and liberal values in the first half-decade of independence.
Murshid’s is a multi-disciplinary approach that relies on theoretical frameworks of social sciences other than history. Interesting and valuable perspectives can emerge and insights can be gleaned from using such frameworks.
For example, using the neoclassical realist framework of international relations, Shafiqur Rahman argues, contra Raghavan, that “not only the separation of the two halves of Pakistan was highly predisposed but also a violent parting was highly likely.” More importantly, the author shows the “pitfalls of memoirs and interviews to construct a narrative plot of historical events while neglecting critical role of structural conditions” in his discussion of Sisson and Rose. For that point alone, the Portland-based researcher should expand this article into a book.
More generally, theoretical frameworks around military involvement in politics or revolutionary movements can be used to understand the role of the army officers or the left in 1971, and the consequences thereof. A genuinely global history of 1971 -- one that links the Bangladeshi struggle with the diaspora communities, citizens’ activism in the West, NGOs, and counterculture zeitgeist of the era -- could be a fascinating read. And if the Chinese archives could be accessed, perhaps some genuinely ground breaking discoveries could come to light.
At the 50th anniversary of the War, there is no shortage of books that could be written about 1971. Meanwhile, what about the books by Bass, Raghavan, and Tripathi? Judged in terms of what they set out to do, the first one is a success, the latter two perhaps less so. But insofar as they all make the reader think about 1971 and many unexplored elements in the existing literature -- they are all successful.
Books reviewed
- The Blood Telegram: Nixon, Kissinger and a Forgotten Genocide by Garry J Bass, Alfred A Knopf, 2013.
- 1971: A Global History of the Creation of Bangladesh by Srinath Raghavan, Harvard, 2013.
- The Colonel who would not Repent: the Bangladesh War and its Unquiet Legacy by Salil Tripathi, Yale, 2014.
Other books
- Dead Reckoning: Memories of the 1971 Bangladesh War by Sarmila Bose, C Hurst & Co, 2011.
- War and Secession: Pakistan, India, and the Creation of Bangladesh by Richard Sisson and Leo Rose, University of California, 1991.
- Sapiens: a Brief History of Humankind by Yuval Noah Harari, Random House, 2015.
- Pakistan: Military Rule or People’s Power by Tariq Ali, William Morrow, 1970.
- Shatabdi Periye by Haider Akbar Khan Rono, Tarafdar Publishers, 2005.
- Ekattur-er Dinguli by Jahanara Imam, Shondhani Publisers, 1986.
- Brave of Heart by Habibul Alam, 2006.
- The Cruel Birth of Bangladesh by Archer K Blood, 2002.
- Surrender at Dacca by JFR Jacob, UPL, 1997.
- The Separation of East Pakistan: the Rise and Realisation of Bengali Muslim Nationalism by Hassan Zaheer, UPL, 2001.
- Women, War, and the Making of Bangladesh: Remembering 1971 by Yasmin Saikia, Duke University, 2011.
- The Spectral Wound: Sexual Violence, Public Memories and the Bangladesh War of 1971 by Nayanika Mookherjee, Duke University, 2015.
- 1971: A People’s History from Bangladesh, Pakistan and India by Anam Zakaria, Penguin Random House, 2019.
- The Sacred and the Secular: Bengal Muslim discourses, 1871-1977 by Tazeen Murshid, Oxford, 1996.
Jyoti Rahman is a reader. He writes about what he reads at www.jrahman.substack.com.