The long awaited and highly anticipated two day-long International Investment Summit 2021 that came to an end on November 29 is reported to have attracted over $2.5 billion worth of investment from domestic and international companies in different sectors.
Considering Bangladesh’s challenges in attracting FDI and the backdrop of the Covid-19 pandemic, this is welcome news.
From an overall perspective, the summit may be declared to be a success since it has achieved its set objectives and goals for the most part.
It has brought further attention and focus on Bangladesh as an investment option in the international front.
By making virtual attendance possible, the summit was able to reach a much larger global audience and place itself into the orbit of many potential international investors who otherwise might not have been able to participate.
Bangladesh has been taking initiatives to attract foreign direct investment (FDI) for a long time.
One of the more recent initiatives was the creation of the Bangladesh Investment Development Authority (BIDA) a few years ago to work exclusively to facilitate FDI into Bangladesh.
This was and is certainly a very positive step in the right direction.
By creating one singular agency whose primary purpose is to encourage and assist in attracting new investment into Bangladesh, the authorities have made it simpler for those foreign investors eyeing Bangladesh as a potential investment destination.
Such potential investors now, in theory, have a one stop agency which can effectively act as a stepping stone into Bangladesh and as a willing partner and guide.
However, this initiative has yet to yield any truly substantive and measurable results. Comparatively, India and Vietnam's FDI is 10-15% of the GDP, Bangladesh's FDI is still hovering between 1-1.5% of the GDP.
In Bangladesh’s 8th Five-Year Plan and the Perspective Plan, it is shown that FDI would amount to around 3%.
When comparing Bangladesh to its closest competitor nations who are also competing for the same pool of FDI, there is no scope of saying that the figures are satisfactory because those countries have already far surpassed Bangladesh in terms of FDI inflow.
Furthermore, analysts routinely point towards Bangladesh’s strong growth figures and how FDI does not measure up to expectations.
As such, our expectations from BIDA are so much more than where we currently are, and we sincerely hope that this important agency will be able to step up to a greater extent.
For this to happen, BIDA must also be given greater levels of power and authority to act on its own and accomplish its laid-out objectives without any interference or bureaucratic roadblocks.
Limitations
Under the current system, it appears that BIDA itself does not have the governing authority in many crucial areas since it still must defer to and obtain permissions and “go ahead” orders from other powerful institutions such as Bangladesh Bank and various ministries.
Basically, BIDA is nowhere near becoming a true one stop shop that it intends to be since it simply does not yet have the policy level authority.
What is deterring FDI inflow to Bangladesh despite the country reaching multiple economic milestones?
The pandemic is one of the reasons for low inflow of FDI in Bangladesh for the last two years and this is the case worldwide as investors were shy about advancing ahead.
What is happening now is that those who have already invested in the country are expanding their business?
In the last fiscal year, it was noted that 63.25 percent of FDI is reinvestment earnings.
That is, existing foreign investors reinvested the profit they made in Bangladesh and only 32% is FDI equity or fresh investment.
In order to increase FDI, Bangladesh will have to brand itself as a country with scope and potential for investment, not just superficially but in substance as well.
Foreign investors must be made to know and believe that there is profit to be made here, and that they would not face restrictions in remitting earned funds back to their home countries.
Foreign investors have often voiced their concerns regarding the ability to repatriate their earnings in Bangladesh to overseas jurisdictions due to the stringent laws and policies barring such outflow of funds from Bangladesh.
Regulatory barriers such as relatively high taxation and still existing overly complicated regulatory frameworks continue to impede FDI.
There are also infrastructure challenges which are a key enabler of investment, although there have been some recent improvements. Bangladesh did not have a deep seaport but now a deep seaport is being set up and a third terminal is being built at the country’s largest international airport in Dhaka.
The nation’s roads and highways are expanding to ease traffic congestion as well as provide better connectivity.
There used to be a crisis with power in the past but that is no longer an issue.
There is also a significant opportunity for FDI to come in for the country's blue economy.
This is especially pertinent following the verdict on the international maritime boundary whereby Bangladesh's area under the sea has expanded.
From the perspective of attracting resource-seeking FDI, Bangladesh needs adequate infrastructure to find oil, gas and minerals from the Bay of Bengal.
Upgraded technology, money and management is required in order to enable this.
India and Myanmar have already started investing in the Bay of Bengal.
Consequently, we are missing out on similar investment opportunities since there is no effective policy framework to attain the natural resources in the blue economy for foreign investment.
The state-owned agency BAPEX does not yet have the capacity.
Market-seeking FDI
Another form of FDI inflow is known as market-seeking FDI.
This occurs when foreign companies come to invest in Bangladesh to gain access into the domestic market.
For instance, foreign banks like Standard Chartered Bank and HSBC have set up operations in Bangladesh to tap into its consumer market.
Many manufacturing companies such as electronics and e-commerce companies, as well as startups, have been investing in Bangladesh due to market-seeking FDI.
However, there is an issue here and that is,the market size in Bangladesh is still relatively small.
For instance, if compared with India, which has a huge economy worth more than three trillion dollars,
Bangladesh is much smaller in scale with an economy worth $400 billion.
Thus, the country's scope of securing market-seeking FDI is still limited in the present.
There is still lots of hope for Bangladesh right now because there is another category of FDI and that is called efficiency-seeking FDI.
In this category, foreign companies come to invest to lower the production cost.
These companies sell the product in the markets around the world.
Securing this category of FDI can lead to a huge inflow of FDI and it is the most attractive form of FDI for Bangladesh at the current instance.
There are two strategic advantages that can be used for bringing in efficiency-seeking FDI into Bangladesh.
First is the demographic advantage due to having a huge young population which naturally leads to having a large trainable labor force that is ready to be utilized.
The second one is geographical advantage. Bangladesh has airways, waterways and land ways and because of it, there is significant scope of capturing large nearby markets such as India, Thailand and China.
Foreign companies can produce quality products in Bangladesh and sell in those markets relatively easily.
Hence the potential for much larger FDI inflow certainly exists in Bangladesh.
For this to occur, some major regulatory reforms combined with automation and further upgrading of technological infrastructure is desperately required.
Too many regulatory activities are still occurring manually, and physical presence is required, which continue to discourage foreign investors.
Now there appears to be resistance to automation and the creation of one stop facilities by the BIDA from various other governmental agencies due to presumed insecurity that the value and strength of such other agencies might be diminished.
If investors and people do not need to go to those agencies anymore then it is worrisome to them because it would eventually result in their own obsolescence and the opportunity for corrupt practices would also disappear in those other institutions.
The desire for FDI is high not just in Bangladesh but also in many other highly competitive nations with far more evolved and advanced regulatory framework and infrastructure and this means that foreign companies have options.
So, it is crucial that Bangladesh also puts in the effort to become a viable option for FDI among its competitors or peers.
Road shows abroad, international summits or export pavilions are not at all enough to give Bangladesh the edge it needs because at the depth of the matter, Bangladesh needs major policy reforms combined with drastic improvements in infrastructure, technology, upskilling and ease of doing business.
Mamun Rashid is a partner with PwC Bangladesh. Views expressed are his own.