OP-ED: A crown peculiar

I spent last week on the Channel Island of Jersey.  Like its sister islands, Guernsey, Alderney and Sark, Jersey nestles in the wide bay of Mont St Michel some fourteen miles off the coast of France.

The history of these islands is a fascinating one. Prior to the invasion of England in 1066, they formed part of the territory owned and controlled by Duke William of Normandy (later William I, the Conqueror of England). They remained an integral component of the Anglo-Norman empire until 1204, when William’s great-great grandson, King John, lost all of his possessions on mainland France to his rival Phillip II.  

The Channel Islands were then offered a choice; they could either retain their fealty to their original Norman masters, or else swear allegiance to the English crown. They opted for the latter and have maintained that direct relationship to the British monarchy ever since. 

With a clear nod to their feudal past, the islands are officially classified as “Peculiars of the Crown.” This means, in practice, that while they are part of Great Britain (GB) they are not part of the United Kingdom (UK). 

Having never really given it much thought until about a week ago, these two terms, GB and UK, have always seemed to me to mean one and the same thing and (so I erroneously thought) could be used interchangeably. 

I now know differently. GB refers to the physical landmasses that make up the British Isles, while the term UK represents the political conglomeration of the islands of Britain. This political structure does not include Jersey or its neighbouring Channel Islands nor the Isle of Man.  Instead, each have their own unique and individual constitutions, laws and political systems. 

Because they owe allegiance directly to the Crown, the Channel Islands do not have any political representation at Westminster but instead, as in Jersey’s case, elect members to the local parliament known as the States Chamber. 

As a result - something I was also surprised to learn this week - Jersey and the other neighbouring islands, although British, have never been a part of the European Union (EU). Although having been spared the divisiveness caused by Brexit elsewhere in Britain the islands have, however, not been immune from its consequences. But more of that later.

Jersey, on the surface at least, seems like any ordinary English county. Its rugged coastline is reminiscent of Cornwall; its lush green interior similar to that of Sussex and its villages have more than an air of East Anglia about them.

Most of the people speak English and conduct their commerce in sterling. Many of the UK’S major high street chains, Morrisons, Next, Marks and Spencers etc, can be found in the Island’s capital St Helier. However, on closer inspection, some of the names of the streets on which these stores are situated are often in French; Route de la Liberation or the delightfully named La Rue Trousse Cotillion or “Pick Up Your Petticoat Street” -- an obvious reference to a time when the roads were considerably less well-paved than they are today.

In the more “real” rural parts of the Island, at least up until the late 1960s, the main language was Jerrias -- a derivative of the French spoken on the Island since Norman times. 

Nowadays, it is estimated that only 3% of islanders speak the language, although it is now being taught as an examined subject in Jersey’s secondary schools.

And yet, curiously, in spite of all of the obvious French connections, there is little love lost between the modern-day inhabitants of the island and France. During my stay this week, the dispute over fishing rights escalated between Jersey and London on the one side and Paris on the other. 

Part of the Brexit agreement signed by the EU and the UK government and which came into force in January this year, allowed London and Paris to grant licences to individual fishing vessels in order for them to continue to ply their trade in each other’s waters -- including in seas around the Channel Islands. 

Known as the Trade and Cooperation Agreement, the deal requires that these licences will only be granted to boat owners who can definitively verify that they had previously fished in these areas.

Since many of the French fishing boats are small and lack even rudimentary GPS tracking equipment, their owners are finding it very difficult to prove their record of fishing in these waters.

Consequently, the UK and Jersey governments, have refused to grant licences to these smaller French vessels. In retaliation the outraged French government has threatened to ban British fishing boats from entering some French ports, has reinforced routine security checks on British lorries coming into and out of the country and has even suggested cutting off Jersey’s electricity supplies, 95% of which comes from the French mainland. 

The French have already seized the British scallop dredger, the Cornelis, and impounded it in Le Havre for supposedly fishing ‘illegally’ in French waters. On paper, the timing of this couldn’t be worse. The French president, Emmanuel Macron, is with the British PM Boris Johnson this week in Glasgow at the COP26 climate conference.

Cynics, however, have suggested that the spat suits both leaders’ political agenda. Macron is fighting a closely run presidential re-election campaign and it plays well to his electorate to, once more, attack perfidious Albion.  It worked well for his hero, Charles de Gaulle, and Macron has calculated that it will work just as well for him. 

For Johnson, it is a golden opportunity to be seen “taking back control” after Brexit and offers up a welcome distraction to Tory backbenchers chaffing at the recent budget announcement of the highest tax levels since the 1950s.

Meanwhile, this leaves Jersey with what I witnessed myself -- a very parable sense of unease at the prospect of power blackouts and a threatened blockade of its harbours by angry French fishermen. 

Surely, a more mature response from its two neighbours, the UK and France, is what is needed now. We are meant to be close allies after all.

Quite what William the Conqueror would make of it all I can only imagine.

Kit Fenwick is a freelance writer and historian.