OP-ED: Going back to our roots

It was an Islamic thinker, Ibn Rushd (known in the West as Averroes), who greatly influenced the evolution of philosophy in separating religion and state. Ibn Rushd translated the works of Aristotle and advocated rationality in public affairs. 

In 1972, Bangladesh became the first constitutionally secular country in South Asia. It was also the first Muslim-majority country in South Asia to declare itself as a secular state. This was a seminal achievement. The Constitution Drafting Committee led by Dr Kamal Hossain must be credited for this achievement. 

From a comparative law perspective, other Muslim-majority nations also pioneered secularism. For example, the Azeri and Turkish republics in the early 20th century gave women the right to vote before many Western nations. The Bangladeshi constitution in 1972 reflected a strong influence of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, particularly the notion of non-discrimination on the basis of religion, race, caste, sex, place of birth, or language. 

India followed Bangladesh’s footsteps in 1976 when its 42nd constitutional amendment included the word “secular” in the text of the Indian constitution. This amendment came into effect on January 3, 1977. Ironically, Bangladesh deleted the word secularism in 1977. 

On April 23, 1977, the Chief Martial Law Administrator arbitrarily enacted The Proclamation (Amendment) Order 1977. This was a brazenly undemocratic amendment of the constitution by the martial law regime. It was akin to an imperial diktat. The Supreme Court of Bangladesh declared this amendment to be illegal and unconstitutional. Hence, secularism was restored by the court in 2010. 

Between 1977 and 2010, secularism was absent in the constitutional text. In 1988, parliament declared Islam as the state religion. After the parliamentary government returned in 1991, the two main governing parties of Bangladesh continued with the provision of the state religion. The principle of secularism now co-exists with Article 2A on the state religion. Article 2A also guarantees equality for all other religious communities.  

According to Article 8, secularism is one of the fundamental principles of state policy. This is reflected across the vast spectrum of Bangladeshi law which has been secular since the colonial period. However, family law continues to be based on religious law as a result of colonial era legislation.

Moreover, a civil marriage in Bangladesh is not possible for a Muslim, Hindu, Buddhist, or Christian unless one renounces his or her faith in these religions. A comprehensive overhaul and reform of family law should be considered to remove existing inequalities. 

Article 12 is the most important article for secularism in the constitution. It calls for the elimination of communalism, religious discrimination, and the misuse of religion in politics. In reality, religion is being widely misused for narrow political ends. Communalism and discrimination still exist. The recent violence against the Hindu community is a testament to the embattled cause of secularism. 

The representation of religious minorities in government, parliament, the bureaucracy, and armed forces has increased. The government has promoted the notion that all citizens are equal in the eyes of the law and that no citizen should be treated as a minority. The population of religious minorities has also slightly increased in the last few years, according to the Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics. 

For 50 years, Bangladesh has celebrated the festivals of its four largest religious communities as national holidays. Secular and religious festivals are a key time for consumer spending. 

But secularism continues to be a politicized and partisan issue. While the Awami League pursues a nominally secular policy, the opposition Bangladesh Nationalist Party’s position is ambiguous to say the least. The current BNP leadership should remember that even Ziaur Rahman acknowledged that the misuse of religion in politics is against the national interest.

It is clear that the Bangladeshi public want a balance between their proud religious identity and the central role of rationality in statecraft. It will be interesting to watch how the separation of religion and state will evolve in the future in Bangladesh. If necessary, an Islamic doctrinal basis should be provided for the separation of religion and statecraft. Bangladesh should be proud that it was the first constitutionally secular state in the subcontinent. 

To end on a note of comparative law, the first amendment to the United States Constitution in 1791 introduced the clause which states that: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” 

To draw an analogy, the 1972 constitution was Bangladesh’s answer to the American first amendment. The 1977 martial law proclamation would be akin to a repeal of the first amendment. The 2010 restoration would be akin to a restoration of the first amendment. 

That is the story of Bangladeshi secularism in the last 50 years. 

Umran Chowdhury works in the legal field.