The budget conundrum – is it too big to be true?

The budget for the FY2013-14 has made history in terms of its size, currently standing at Tk2.22tn (16% increase from FY2012-13) and a 275 fold increase from the first budget in FY1972-73. Despite the optimism and confidence exuded by our octogenarian finance minister, the fact remains that the budget target is deemed over ambitious, considering the upcoming political upheaval, national election and handover of power from this government to the next.

It must be kept in mind that the current budget has manifold agendas and is not solely restricted to economic ones. As a consequence, this budget is designed to be more of an election manifesto that the government intends to project to woo voters for the upcoming election.

Economic policy experts have squarely criticised the budget parameters and corresponding GDP projection of 7.2% as “surreal” and “impossible to achieve.” In contrast, the government has retorted back with the FM espousing confidence based on his government’s budget implementation track record. But interestingly, the bone of contention remains the funding of the budget of such magnitude, which is mainly projected to come from tax revenue (61.2%). However, considering the historical tax revenue collection trend, achieving the desired scenario seems highly unlikely.

A sneak peek into this year’s budget reveals the different aspects of expenditures and revenue sourcing.  The figure below summarizes the main component of the proposed budget.

Expenditure variables

The proposed budget has made the highest allocation for public administration at Tk320.9bn, which is substantially higher than the corresponding figures in FY2012-13 budget. This higher allocation will most likely be disbursed in the form of incremental salary for government employees, thus resulting in possible inflationary bouts. Historically, all salary hikes for government employees, without corresponding increase in productivity, has resulted in demand pull inflationary tendency. It is expected that this round of salary hike will have similar implications.

Alarmingly, interest payment for loans occupies the second highest component, due to large scale government borrowing from the financial system. Considering the continued incremental budget deficit and government’s sustained dependence on the financial market, the figure is set to increase further in the coming years. In the future, higher allocation for loan servicing will definitely reduce the pie for other developmental projects and may eventually turn the budget untenable unless tax revenues are increased dramatically.

The energy sector allocation has increased in absolute terms but the percentage allocation has declined compared to the previous budget. According to the figure below, we can see that the current budget allocation for power sector stands at Tk114bn. But if we look at the statistics from the past two fiscal years, we realise that the implementation rate against the proposed budget was below 70%. Under this context, it seems highly unlikely that the project implementation trend will dramatically rise. Therefore, actual budget spending will be significantly less than the budgetary estimates.

The energy policy is mainly attuned towards the quick rental power plant solution, as no substantial funds have been allocated for constructing new power plants. Since most existing power plants are run by gas oriented turbines, government needs to ensure adequate supply of gas and ensure FDIs, both for discovering new gas generation sources and also for the power sector.

The agriculture sector funding has experienced a marked decline as the sector only received 7.85% allocation against 10.48% the previous year. The government had to reduce allocation for subsidies to Tk90bn against Tk120bn for FY2012-13. A decline for agriculture subsidy will increase dependence on foreign sources for meeting demand of essential commodities and thereby erode the country’s self-sustainability in availing local demand for vital food grains. Additionally, since a major portion of the country’s population is engaged in farming, lower agriculture sector budgetary allocation will contribute to further disparity in income between rural and urban areas.  

Government has allocated significant funding for the communications sector, setting aside funds for commencing the Padma Bridge project. The proposed communication budget of Tk182.33bn has been allocated to both Communications (Tk55.5bn) and Railway ministries (Tk55.89bn). This seems like a worthwhile investment because it will ensure sustainability of economic growth while improving supply chain management.

However, self financing of Padma Bridge may have detrimental impacts on fiscal budget balance. Although, the government is planning to utilise $200m of India’s line of credit along with funds from Islamic Development Bank (IDB), the overall budgetary balance will be hampered. According to experts, financing the bridge from internal sources may result in bigger budget deficits in the future, forcing governments to resort to borrowing from the banking sector, which may eventually lead to the so called “crowding out effect.” Additionally, the balance of payment situation may deteriorate due to large scale procurement from external sources while constructing the bridge. 

The ADP implementation rate is going to be higher than expected as government will frantically try to implement projects in accordance to election pledges. However, if revenue streams are not matched with expenditure trends, government will have to resort to domestic sources for financing development programmes.

Revenue variables

Government has set an ambitious target for NBR, which many experts feel will not be achieved. The revenue target of Tk1.361tn for FY2013-14 is a huge jump (above 20%) from previous year’s revenue growth targets. According to former NBR chairman, Mr Abdul Majid, it will be very difficult for NBR to achieve the growth target which constitutes 11.4% of country’s GDP. The tax collection situation may further exacerbate owing to unrelenting political turmoil, declining private sector investments and stagnating imports.

Foreign grant and loan target has been set at $3bn, which was $2.2bn for FY2013-14. However, the actual foreign aid collection for FY2012-13 stood at 1.2bn, which is way short of last year’s target. Given the scenario, it can be safely assumed that the revenue target set for the current budget is unlikely to be met.

The budget stipulates domestic funding of Tk260bn, which mainly constitutes selling of savings certificate and lending from state-owned banks (SOBs). Considering the uncertainty in achieving tax revenues, government borrowing from the local market may shoot up leading to crowding out of private sector credit funds (see chart below). This may eventually impact the interest rate, thus further depressing the private sector investment. Higher bank borrowing will also increase the government’s burden of servicing these debts in the future.

Overall, the revenue strategy devised by the government is more of an after-thought rather than something concrete. The revenue figures have been chalked out keeping in mind IMF’s restriction of keeping budget deficit within 5% threshold. The question remains regarding the extent to which the current budget will assist the economy in sustaining the aspirational GDP growth target.

The GDP factor

The current year’s GDP projection at 7.2% is well on its way to remain unfulfilled. A closer analysis of FY2012-13 performance reveals that almost all sectors have performed below par which eventually led to the provisional GDP growth of 6%. The table below delineates sector wise contribution to cumulative GDP growth.

In FY2012-13, the agriculture sector has contributed 2.2% to GDP against projection of 4.4%. Secondary sector has also underperformed with contribution of 9% against projection of 9.9%. Service sector growth has been disappointing as it uncharacteristically failed to achieve target growth of 7.1%. This situation is expected to aggravate further in FY2013-14 as the RMG sector battles to retain GSP and as private investments further plummet in the wake of political uncertainty and amid higher cost of funds.

Impact Assessment and some Caveats

Despite aspirations to achieve fiscal objectives, the government’s efforts will be hindered by bureaucratic bottle necks, political unrest, wide spread corruptions, supply side shocks and recession in international market. The recent Rana Plaza tragedy has placed renewed pressure on Bangladesh’s RMG industry, which may have far reaching impact on the country’s economic performance. The remittance growth remains a silver lining and has contributed to a strong balance of payment position and healthy foreign currency reserve.

The electricity generation capability has increased during the government’s tenure, although the present shortage remains at 2000MW level.  The gap will be further mitigated as some worn out power plants are repaired and as more rental power plants start generating electricity. However, since many rental power plants are run by HFO, increase in international oil price may force government to subsidise oil price from budgetary allocation.

The political unrest is expected to escalate post Ramadan, especially if the government decides to organise the election within the current framework. Continued strikes/unrest may send negative signals abroad and will deter future FDIs, while export oriented industries such as RMG, will fail to deliver goods within stipulated time. Political turmoil may depress private investments and consumer spending, leading to lower tax revenues for NBR.

The agriculture sector may suffer due to lowering of subsidies which may result in depressed economic conditions in rural economy. Conversely, price of basic essentials will increase causing cost push inflation within the economy.  Additionally, due to decline in budget spending on social welfare expenditure in the budget, the social safety net among rural community may further decline. This may further encourage the trend of rural-urban migration, thereby exacerbating the already worsening situation.

Concluding Remarks

The proposed budget aims to converge on the government’s electoral pledges with fiscal reality. Although the budget has focused on several crucial and pertinent components, the viability of many of these components remain doubtful, largely owing to lack of adequate funding.

It must be kept in mind that a budget is merely a plan and the reality will be significantly different. We expect the revised and approved budget to reflect practical ground realities as opposed to whims. 

The authors are the co-founders of LightCastle Partners, an emerging market specialised business planning and intelligence firm. Learn more about them at          www.lightcastlebd.com.