We've a problem with how we measure the economy. GDP -- that is gross domestic product -- can be problematic. We use it because it's about the best number that we can calculate in something close to real time. It's therefore the best we've got as a guide to what we should be doing.
However, as with so many other economic numbers, we've got to grasp how it's calculated and thus the meaning of what is calculated. If we don't do that then we can be led into error. This is, I fear, what has happened when people discuss -- as in this newspaper -- the female labour force participation rate.
It is true that as this rises -- as a greater portion of the women of the country go to work in formal jobs for wages -- then GDP rises. But there's also a possible reaction to this which is “so what?” More women working for wages is not a good thing in and of itself. Nor is higher GDP a good thing in and of itself. This is something that becomes clearer when we think about the construction of GDP itself.
It was John Maynard Keynes who pointed out one of the problems with GDP calculations -- when a man marries his housekeeper then GDP declines. The point being that GDP only measures economic activity which takes place in markets. Activity which takes place within the household isn't part of it. So, someone who is paid to come and do the cooking, cleaning, and so on (and we'll leave out other more private possible services that a wife might provide and a housekeeper perhaps not) is counted as part of GDP. The marriage brings that same work -- and likely the same flow of funds too -- into the household where it disappears from GDP.
This problem was known back when the entire concept of GDP was first invented -- that joke was made at that time. But we do need to recall this now, for not to do so can lead us into error.
The argument being made is that if more women went out to work, for wages, then GDP would rise. This is entirely true. Because GDP measures people working for money and doesn't measure those working within the household. We're told that women -- on average, of course -- spend only 1.2 hours a day on paid employment and 5.9 hours on unpaid domestic and care work. Men spend 6.1 hours on that paid work.
If all the women went out to work cooking for another household, taking care of someone else's children, and got paid wages for doing so then yes, GDP would rise. But we'd also have exactly the same amount of cooking being done, childcare taking place -- we'd have swapped wives for housekeepers (except, hopefully, for those more personal services).
We would not, in fact, have changed anything very much, but GDP would rise. The conclusion of this being that more women working for wages might indeed raise GDP but it's not something we should have as a goal. Not a measure which actually advances society at all.
This is not, of course, the end of the story though. Perhaps some people taking care of the children collectively -- a nursery, a school -- means that we need fewer people taking care of children. Then that extra labour that we've freed up can indeed go off to do something new. That not only adds to GDP that really does make us richer -- by exactly the amount of the value of that new thing being done.
Equally, perhaps some women would prefer to go to work for wages while others would prefer to be childcarers (or do the cooking, the cleaning, whatever). More people being able to live their lives as they wish is also us all getting richer, whether that has an effect upon GDP or not. This is also true of those who find their fulfilment in running their homes instead of working for wages -- more people doing what they desire to do makes us richer.
The deeper point here isn't in fact about GDP, nor women working. It's that near all of the economic numbers we use are not, in fact, the measurement we'd really like to be making. They're nearly always proxies -- something that is close to what we'd like to measure but not actually the thing itself. This means that we shouldn't be using our economic numbers as targets in quite the way we often do.
More women going out to work for wages would raise GDP. So what? GDP isn't the thing we want to maximize. More people being able to do more of what those people want to do is -- we want to maximize human utility. We have no measure for human utility, we use GDP instead. But GDP is that proxy and so we fall into error if we try to maximize the proxy -- GDP, instead of the actual target -- human utility.
Which leaves us with the actual answer here to female labour force participation. We must have a system whereby if women wish to work for wages, they may. Equally, if they prefer to run their household, then so be it. This applies to men too, of course. Maximizing the choices that can be made maximizes utility, not maximizing GDP.
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London