Financial speculation in food prices can be a very dangerous thing -- raising prices for no good reason in times of shortage. Financial speculation in food prices makes no difference at all to food prices. Both of these statements are true -- it depends upon which sort of financial speculation we are talking about.
One of the sadder points of the modern age is that not enough distinction is made between the two types. The Bengal Famine in 1943 was a ghastly, horrible event. But as Amartya Sen has pointed out -- his Nobel is largely for this and other famine related work -- it was largely the result of the bad type of food speculation. When people took real, extant, food and stored it in the expectation of higher prices in the future -- hoarding that is.
This newspaper has recently carried an article which fails to make the correct distinction. Sadly it's by a “lecturer in Development Economics” which just makes the error worse. For the claim is made that speculation in futures and options in food changes real world food prices. This is simply wrong, that's not the way the world works at all.
Some parts of the analysis are correct -- it is true that the existence of these financial and purely speculative markets allows farmers to transfer risk. Also, the consumers of farm products get to transfer price risk -- all of that ends up with the speculators. Which is good -- we're always happy when people who don't want to face risk don't have to, when those who want to play with it get to do so.
The error though is in this “The price of a physical contract is based on the price of a specific futures contract.”
No.
We have two systems running. There's the price of the commodity -- say, wheat -- in the physical world. A shipload of wheat, in this place, right now, is worth some number of dollars. That's the physical price. Pay it and you get the wheat, today -- maybe tomorrow -- when the cheque clears.
The second system is that of all those futures and options and loud men shouting at each other over telephones. That's the ethereal market, the speculation. It's much larger, hundreds of times larger than the physical market. You can trade wheat for next week, next year, different types, in different places -- but all that is being traded is the pieces of paper.
The claim made above is that the changes in the futures price change the physical price. This is not so. All futures, all options, as they come to their end date, become worth the physical price. The physical does not rise or fall to meet the future -- the future always, but always, comes to meet the physical.
This is, of course, important. One thought might be that someone working on development issues, well, we'd want them to know this. But rather more important is that all sorts of think that something should be done to curb these speculators. Because, look, people playing with money hurt us folk out in the real world.
But if that's not happening, if the influence runs the other way, then there's no reason to limit this type of speculation, is there? For the other part of it is still true -- it enables farmers and consumers to lay their price risk onto the speculators. And if there's no real world effect from this on physical food prices then why wouldn't we let it just carry on? Actually, given that we like risk being placed with those who want it, taken off those who don't, we'd not just allow it, we'd encourage it.
The other sort of speculation, where real physical stocks are tied up is another matter. We may or may not want this to happen. But the financial speculation in those futures markets? That's fine.
It was Paul Krugman -- he also has a Nobel in Economics, alongside Sen, so we should listen to him too -- who pointed out that in the absence of rising physical stocks it is not possible for financial speculation to affect real world food prices.
Which is very much the same statement as the one I've just made. All that froth of futures in food doesn't change the physical world price. The futures price approaches the physical, not the other way around.
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London