A lack of uniformity

Our private universities have a grading problem. With nearly 100 private universities in operation currently, only a few of them have proven their quality to be satisfactory. The well-known and reputed ones like NSU, BRAC, EWU, IUB, AIUB, and a few others have always been in a race among themselves, which, in a way, is healthy for the educational environment on a broad spectrum. However, there are events and segments within that race which might turn out to be rather hurtful for the general students in the long run. Separate grading systems being one of such segments. 

To understand the various and diverse grading systems practiced by our private universities, parting the universities in two categories might help:  Category A, whose grade points start from 0.7 at the bottom and culminate up to 4, the maximum; category B, which follows the same scale for the maximum at 4 but maintains a bottom line at 2. Needless to say, both the categories put a zero and maintain uniformity to the student who fails to attain passing marks. No wonder they differ in passing marks as well. While  50% (some even count 60%) is the passing percentage for category A and 40%  for category B.

Let's have an imaginary tour “around the grades” -- suppose a student from any university from category A attains 50% marks in total after their final assessment and their friend gets the same marks from a category B university. For the two of them the situation will not be the same. The grade point achieved by the one from category A would be devastating, while the other one might not be that unhappy. In plain words, two completely different situations would come into play because of the differences in grading systems in two sets of universities, despite the similarities in the percentage of marks obtained by the two.

The student from category A will get a grade point of only  0.7 for the marks they have attained in the exam but the same percentage of marks will lead their friend from category B to have a grade points up to 2.50.  Sadly, a 0.7 could be devastating enough to plunge the CGPA into the abyss.

What about the students who usually get 70% marks throughout their education? Interestingly, a 70% marks would easily lead a student to a grade point of 3.50 if they are from a category B university, whereas the story would be troubling for the one from category A. Unfortunately, 70% will not  be sufficient for a student from category A to achieve a grade point of more than 2.70, whereas  the one from category B will get hold of grade point upto 2.75 with only 55% or less.

Moreover, making it worse, some of the category A universities go to the further extent of setting the passing marks at 60% and requiring  80% for a grade point of only 2.70.  On the other hand, 80% marks is the highest benchmark and allows students to get the maximum grade point if they are from a category B university. This is some unbelievable stuff.

We may think of  exercising a far more lenient student evaluation method by universities from category A, but such thoughts don't linger for long when the category owns names like BRAC, NSU, EWU, IUB, and AIUB -- all of which have already proven their quality in more than one count be it ranking, the job market, or otherwise. However, the categorization I propose here has not, in any sense, been done in terms of the reputation of the instructions; rather, it is done solely on the basis of the process of how the universities grade their students.

While it is also true that the universities should have the liberty to maintain their own grading systems, in a county like ours, where CGPA matters more than anything in the primary selection -- be it a job or admission test -- allowing separate grading systems with such huge differences does no one any good.

The University Grant Commission (UGC) was established under the University Grant Commission Ordinance 1973 and has the authority to hold tight the bridles of our private universities to ensure better education. We have seen that the UGC has not given permission to private universities to offer and confer PhD degrees and has kept pressuring private universities for shifting their in-city campuses to permanent ones.

However, the commission seems the least bit bothered, or not even bothered at all, when it comes to separate grading systems practiced by some private universities. Although the commission had once issued an office order requesting every public and private university to maintain a uniform grading system -- which, evidently, the category B universities are following -- the request has yet to have any effect on the universities categorized hereinabove as category A.

Private universities are established and being operated under the Private University Act 2010 and the universities are bound to abide by this specific piece of legislation. This act also provides scope for the UGC to apply its supervisory measures for the greater good of the general students.  

Graduates from these universities are entering the job market or seeking admission for higher education, and in both cases CGPA matters a lot. Situations are no more alien where one student with 75% marks is not making it to the job interviews or to the final list of selected candidates in a higher educational institute while the other one is sealing it with a much lower percentage of marks.

Being the overseer of these universities, it is the UGC's duty to alleviate the pains that the students are going through due to the “irresponsible” attitudes of some of these universities. The commission needs to act now.  

Md Tayeb-Ul-Islam Showrov is an Advocate of the Supreme Court.