According to this newspaper there is a Letter of Credit crisis in Bangladesh. Importers can't use them because the banks don't have the dollars to back them up. According to the Bangladesh Bank, again in this newspaper, this is nonsense, also that the problem will be solved in January -- meaning the problem isn't nonsense if it's only going to be solved in three months' time.
Reality here is that there isn't an LC crisis, nor is there a dollar shortage. What there is is the central bank, Bangladesh Bank, being damn stupid. If we stop them doing that then the other problems simply vanish. Because they are the results of the central bank being, well, damn stupid.
It's true that this is only the first stirrings, the first steps on that downward plunge. But it is still true, the mistake being made is what imploded Sri Lanka. You cannot have a shortage of foreign currency if you have a floating exchange rate. The only way that Bangladesh can have a shortage of US dollars is if someone is trying to fix the price of US dollars. As the only people who would even try to fix the price are the central bank, then if we have a shortage of dollars we've got to examine what the central bank is doing.
And they are trying to fix the price.
In fact, they're intervening in all sorts of ways to try and keep US dollars, when priced in Taka, nice and cheap. The problem with this being true of any sort of price fixing. You can achieve the price you want but not the supply or demand. Or, of course, you can have supply and demand balancing but then you cannot control the price. A shortage -- a shortage that means banks cannot open LCs -- is not just evidence but proof perfect that the central bank is being damn stupid and trying to control the price.
No, think about this for a moment. In any market we have three things: We have the supply -- this can be money, potatoes, telecoms bandwidth -- and we have the demand for those same things. The supply varies with price, demand varies with price, so there's a price at which supply and demand meet. That is, by definition, the market price. For the market price is the price at which all who are willing to buy at that price can do so, all who are willing to sell at that price can also do so.
This definition works the other way around too -- if some cannot buy at the current price, or if some cannot sell, then what we've got there is not, in fact, the market price.
The actual problem currently is that varied banks cannot gain access to the dollars they need in order to be able to create and then pay off LCs. So, people cannot import things because they cannot pay for them. Therefore, people are going without things that they'd like. Why? Because Bangladesh Bank is trying to fix the price of US dollars. Which, inevitably, means that there is a mismatch between the supply and demand of US dollars and so some people cannot buy them and cannot, therefore, buy things which must be paid for in dollars.
As I said when discussing Sri Lanka's implosion: “You can only have a foreign exchange shortage if you're trying to fix the price of that foreign exchange.” This is not some oddity of the free market, classically liberal economics nor is it some invention of mine. It's a statement about the universe we inhabit.
The LC crisis, such as it is, is because the central bank is trying to support (which is a polite phrase meaning “keep higher than it should be”) the exchange rate. Stop the Bangladesh Bank from doing anything so damn foolish and all the other problems cease to be.
It is indeed true that the government solves some collective problems that we have. Those who govern tend to hold that their sway extends very much further than it does. Which does mean that the solution to many, but not all, of our problems is that the government simply stop doing what it is currently doing. This is one of those situations. If Bangladesh Bank stops trying to control the dollar exchange rate then the LC problem disappears. So, obviously, that's what should be done.
I agree, I am temperamentally inclined to think that less government is a solution to much of life. In this specific instance I am also correct. If you have a free market exchange rate then you cannot, by definition, have a shortage of foreign exchange.
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London