Wealth and forgotten virtues
Publish : 03 Jun 2013, 08:34
In sync with the latest Bollywood tunes, corpulent men move with the giddiness of children, tumbling and spilling everywhere inside this ivory palace, an exclusive gentlemen’s club in the finest part of Chittagong.
I came to this city to teach Asian religion and philosophy at a local university, taking on a position that allows me to mingle with privileged members of society. Foreigners like me are in favour here, and I have welcomed the attention and opportunities that come my way.
So when a Bangladeshi-Canadian colleague assured me I would see the best of Chittagong gathered tonight, I said yes without hesitation, hopping on a CNG to a leafy neighbourhood where a faux neo-classical mansion stands staffed by courteous waiters complete with bowties and smartly pressed black plants.
My colleague whispers into my left ear, awestruck by the sight of powerful men who surround us. Look at the government minister here, a hotel magnet there. But above all, I am told, I must behold the garment factory owners who each command an untold fortune. They are living symbols of Bangladesh’s economic miracle. They are the future of this country.
So I watch them shake — the minister and the hotel magnate and the garment factory owners and all — denuded of modesty by the plentiful alcohol and privacy this club affords. Singers squeeze every ounce of virtuosity from their lungs, hungry for taka bills dropping like petals from heaven.
This might be the most wanton display of debauchery I have seen since moving here, but it is not the only one of its kind. The best of Chittagong like to parade their wealth and status in public. They are not ashamed of their success and its spoils.
There is that vanity café on Mohammed Ali Road with virtually no customers, run by the wife of a well-connected businessman, wedding parties featuring thousands of guests at cricket stadiums, strewn with lights as numerous as the stars. A suitcase of one university director magically yields countless bars of Lindt chocolate bars, brought back from overseas travel and generously handed out to visitors by the dozens.
Children of the affluent saturate an SAT testing site, spurred on by parents who believe them destined for Harvard and Princeton and are willing to spend what it takes.
The lifestyle and desires of the rich and powerful in Chittagong may not register as the most serious problem affecting Bangladesh, but to everyone, including this foreigner, their pursuits stand in stark contrast to crumbling public infrastructure and entrenched poverty of the growing metropolis.
Shiny condos and boutiques and restaurants frequented by the newly rich rise out of slums quickly torn down to make space for the upper class. Tall gates manned by uniformed security lead out to roads which, despite being paved anew, are pockmarked like victims of some terrible disease whose name might be corruption.
Bangladesh is a dynamic country in the process of emerging from poverty, mostly thanks to an $18bn garment industry that provides jobs to nearly 4m people. The overall living standard is rising, the GDP is growing, and there are greater rights for women assembling clothes and earning an income. But as we all know, things are still far from perfect.
The money flowing into the country has had an uneven effect on the population, allowing some to sustain an opulent lifestyle bordering on the absurd, while leaving others to risk their lives for a modest salary of $40 per month.
Teaching Asian religion puts me in an awkward position of having to explain this inequality to my students. During our lessons on Islam, I emphasised that this tradition born out of Arabian sands started as a stance against injustice and cruelty.
One of the central tenets of Islam arguably is charity, and caring for the wellbeing of others is an obligation all Muslims must strive to fulfil. Students nodded, then questioned why do we not see this ideal in action on the streets of Bangladesh? Why do the rich of this predominantly Muslim country not seem to care for those who are less fortunate?
The Rana Plaza tragedy has put garment manufacturers on the defensive, and the main argument we hear from them is that they are not the only ones to shoulder the blame for disasters now routine in apparel production.
It is supposedly the fault of a few factory operators, unlicensed criminal elements trying to cash in on the reputation of what is, for the most part, a good, clean business. And it is the fault of Western apparel giants and their customers, concerned only with price and style, who prevent meaningful workplace safeguards even as they hypocritically clamour for them.
There is truth to the view that the collapse in Savar is the result of many forces at work. But as I reflect on my memories of the Chittagong elite’s blindingly conspicuous consumption, I wonder to what extent the masters of Bangladesh’s industrial sector will ever see themselves as responsible for the lives of their fellow citizens.
I ask if they realise that the great inequality exemplified by their way of life, clearly contravening teachings of their religion, undermines their self-identification as good, clean entrepreneurs with no blood on their hands.
I have my doubt that they see it this way, having tried to engage fellow party guests in a discussion over the ethics of garment production.
When the conversation turns toward the subject of working conditions, something stiffens in the air, and I am flatly told that the business owners have already given their greatest gift to the people: employment. They will not be held accountable for anything else.
This act of charity has proven to be decidedly deadly, with fires and destruction that are starting to ruin more lives than they save. And the onus is increasingly on garment kings of Bangladesh, hitherto sealed inside air-conditioned cars and prestigious addresses, away from the sweaty masses that form the majority of this country, to reach out to those who work for them, and to do more than just bestow a salary.
It may finally be time for them to think about acting like the good Muslims they claim to be, instead of holding themselves to the barest minimum standard demanded by global capitalism.
But nobody can think straight when the party is still on and whiskey abundantly flows. Next to me, a blonde American friend of mine is coaxed into a smooth salsa routine by a married Bangladeshi industrialist in his fifties, erudite, charming and clearly enjoying the illicitness of the moment. Her alabaster skin glistens with beads of sweat under the spotlight. He kisses her on the neck. The crowd goes wild.