Those gig economy companies -- the food delivery and informal economy ones -- are sometimes not paying fair wages, benefits, and even offer poor working conditions. This is, of course, an outrage. The thing is though, what do we do about such an outrage?
The report was mentioned in this newspaper (Fairwork Bangladesh Ratings 2022) and details that some of those informal economy workers just aren't gaining a fair shake of the stick. At which point we do indeed want to think about what we can do to make this situation better.
One starting point is to note that, whatever the level of wages or of working conditions, there will always be some who are defined as gaining unfair access to them. Simply because that's how we humans work. “Fair” tends to be defined as about what the average is or even a little better than that. So, as the economy grows, we all get richer -- what is fair rises.
Adam Smith pointed this out with his mention of a linen shirt. Not having a linen shirt does not make you poor. But if you live in a society where not being able to afford a linen shirt means people think you are poor then, well, in that society you are poor if you cannot afford a linen shirt. Everyone's definition of what is fair changes with the general level in that society. That's just how humans work, by comparing with the world around us.
But we can also go to a deeper economic level here. Why are these people not gaining fair wages, decent working conditions? We might say it's because the capitalists want to exploit them. That could even be true, capitalists always do. But that just moves the argument one step further back -- why are the capitalists able to exploit in the first place?
The answer there is that wages for any particular job, or any particular person, are not defined by what the employer is willing to pay. Rather, by what the employer has to pay to get the job done. And what is it that forces the employer to pay higher wages?
That other employers are paying higher wages. Or, we can turn that same point the other way around. The wages of any individual are determined by the other jobs that the same person can get.
If this employer, here, is willing to pay Tk8,000 a month and this one over there only Tk3,000, then the second employer will only get labourers if the first has no more positions to offer. Similarly, if a worker can go and get Tk8,000 a month then why would they suffer to work for only Tk3,000?
So, the wages that any worker can get will be determined by what every other employer is offering. Not, at all, what this specific and one boss is offering, but what every other boss in the economy is offering. To complete the logical circuit again, each boss must offer enough wages to tempt workers away from going to work for someone else instead.
So, what is it that explains low wages for some people? No, it's not that desire of the capitalists to exploit. It's the absence of enough capitalists. Or, at least, enough successful capitalists. For the more successful businesses we have, the greater the demand for labour and so the higher the wages must be offered to get anyone to turn up for work.
The standard textbook proof of this is the wages of a bus driver or a barber. Whether in Sweden or Bangladesh, both will be using pretty much the same tools to do the same job while taking the same amount of time. But the two in Sweden will be paid very much higher wages than the two, the bus driver and the barber, in Bangladesh. The reason why is because other Swedish jobs pay very much more than other Bangladeshi jobs.
What determines wages is the alternative wages on offer to that same worker. From the employers' side, the wages he must pay depend upon what every other employer is offering. So, the more employers offering the more jobs the higher wages will be.
Which gives us our solution to low wages and bad working conditions. Grow the economy and wages will rise while working conditions become better. Yes, of course, as our intuition and belief in what is fair rises, we will still have those allegations that some wages/conditions are unfair. But it really is true that the solution to low wages is a larger economy.
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London