THE LAST WORD BY TIM WORSTALL

A simple solution

When the government complains of a problem being caused by the government itself, then perhaps it's time for a little rethink on what is being done by the government? 

The only problem with this, as a logical starting point, is that this just never is the way things work out. 

Instead, the government continues to do yet ever more things masking that original mistake. 

The specific example here is the foreign exchange rate and the stock of foreign exchange. 

The government is trying to control the price then complaining about the volume available -- the world just doesn't work that way.

Let’s get to the basics. 

We have the supply of something, we have the demand for that same thing. Both of those vary with the price. 

This is that little lesson in that chart on the first two pages of every economics textbook ever -- the supply and demand curves. 

As the price rises more people are willing to supply and fewer people want that thing. 

As it falls the same process goes into reverse – more will want and fewer supply. 

It is that variable price which leads to the balance of the supply and the demand. 

By that very definition the market price is the one at which everyone who wants some at that price gets some, everyone willing to sell at that price does so. 

That's simply what the market price is, the one that clears the market. 

Every willing participant gets what they want.

What this also means is that you cannot control both the volume, either of supply or demand, and also the price. 

If you try to change how much is available, or how much people either want or are allowed to have, by definition you have changed the price. 

Equally, the only way that everyone can get what they want is if we use that market price. 

For that’s what it is, the price at which everyone can gain that what they desire. 

So, if we do use that market price then we cannot have a shortage -- because we've just started by defining the market price as being the one at which there is no shortage, nor any surplus.

Yes, it is a circular argument. 

But then many correct arguments are entirely circular. 

This is so, this is true, simply because this is the way it is.

Once we've grasped this we can look on in wonder at the government's actions regarding the foreign exchange rate. 

There's a worry that the reserves -- the amount the country has to use to send to foreigners to pay for things -- aren't high enough. 

That volume isn't right, that is. 

We've also got the government insisting that the price or foreign exchange, the rate, must be controlled. 

To the point that banks must all work on very small profit margins because, well, “reasons.” 

The government is trying not just to control the exchange rate, but also the price of the banks' services in dealing with foreign exchange.

Now look back up a couple of paragraphs to our very simple explanation of reality. 

You cannot control both the volume and the price of something. 

What is the government trying to do? 

Control both the forex price and also the volume of it available. 

That just doesn't work, it's one of those things the universe doesn't allow us to do. 

The government should stop trying that.

If we actually have a proper free market in foreign currency then we don't, in fact, need reserves anyway. 

Because, by definition, the free market price is the price we can go and buy some when we want some. 

That's actually what it is.

Now, we'd probably not want to have absolutely zero dollars in the central bank, having a few around is a sensible backstop. 

If only because not everyone else out there understands this point about how markets and prices work, so we need to keep them happy in their ignorance. 

But what we should actually do is leave the banks to buy and sell foreign exchange at whatever price they can -- and at whatever profit margin they can get -- and then stop worrying about the reserves. 

The whole point of having such a free market is that, when we want some dollars, or pounds, or yuan, we can just go and buy some. 

The only management of the market we should do is to make sure that there are lots of banks competing against each other to do this.

The government can solve the foreign exchange market problems in Bangladesh simply by not getting involved in the foreign exchange market in Bangladesh. 

Sometimes the answers to difficulties really are that simple.

Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London