THE LAST WORD BY TIM WORSTALL

Is Biman on its way to a collision course?

This newspaper calls for Biman, the government owned airline, to be privatized -- and quite rightly too. 

The argument against privatization is that it will prevent politics from directing how the airline runs. That's the point of having a state-owned company, after all. 

That politics and politicians should be able to influence what happens and how, instead of it being merely some money-grubbing capitalist enterprise. 

The thing is, in a neat piece of serendipity, that's also the argument for privatization. 

So that politics and politicians are not able to interfere in the running so much that it merely becomes a money-grubbing capitalist organization.

We've even got a -- slightly odd, to be fair -- proof of how this works. 

The British water and energy companies used to be owned by the British government and they weren't run all that well. 

They were privatized and some of them are now owned by foreign governments. 

They're not perfect, no one would claim that, but they're much better run than they used to be.

Which gives us that little logical problem. 

For example, why can the French government run a water company in Britain when the British government can't run a water company in Britain? 

Or at least, why can the French run one better than the British? 

My answer is, and I agree it's a slightly odd one, that when the French government is running something in Britain then they don't have to worry about politics. 

They can just be capitalists and run it for the money -- or, as we might also say, run it efficiently. 

But the British government running on in Britain is subject to all those stresses of domestic politics. 

The unions will start to use the votes of their members to gain increased wages, just as an example.

That is, the problem of a state-owned company, of a government run one, isn't quite that the government cannot run things. 

It's that if the government owns one in its own country then inevitably how it is run becomes a subject of local and domestic politics. 

Things that the government must, of course, take note of. 

It's exactly this that leads to the inefficiencies.

The benefit of privatization -- even if it ends up being run by a foreign government -- is that it takes the organization entirely out of domestic politics, shields it from those pressures, and allows management to organise matters efficiently.

Now, yes, Biman is a particularly extreme case of inefficiency and whether anyone would be willing to actually pay for it is something we're likely to find out. 

The answer may well be no, or at least, not much. But then, that's also rather the point. 

An airline in a rapidly growing economy should be worth a great deal of money. 

That it isn't is the evidence we need towards its inefficiency. 

Having an airline that was being run efficiently would be of great benefit to the wider economy as well. 

So, as this newspaper’s editorial says, privatize it. 

Having a better Biman will be worth it.

But the point here is that it doesn't matter who it is sold to. 

Well, perhaps try to make sure that it's not a known crook and so on, but other than that, whether the buyer is a private sector organization, or some part of a foreign government, that doesn't really matter. 

The one organization that we don't want running it is the government of Bangladesh.

To repeat the point, the argument in favour of having a state-run company -- like an airline -- is so that politics and politicians can trump commercial efficiency. 

Which is also the point of not having a state-owned company: Because we prefer the commercial efficiency over the problems which come with having politics and politicians ignoring that required efficiency.

 

Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London