Brothers in arms

Sri Lanka has gone to seed. And the world has to thank the brothers Mahinda and Gotabaya for the chaos in which the people of Sri Lanka find themselves. These brothers, believing that the country was their fiefdom, brought in their other siblings and sons and nephews and indeed nearly their whole clan into the hallways and passages of power, and were happy in the delusion that nothing could come in the way of their happiness.

In the process, they have left Sri Lanka without money, without foreign exchange reserves, without fuel, and without food. Having done the damage, both brothers are now on the run, with no one quite certain where they remain holed up in the country. Mahinda, the former president who became prime minister courtesy of Gotabaya, fled Colombo weeks ago. And now Gotabaya, the beleaguered president, has little chance of returning to office.

The tragedy of Sri Lanka is not that its people are now baying for the blood of those who have brought them to this pass. It is that the Rajapaksas found it so easy to commandeer a whole country for themselves and do to it what ancient conquerors of civilized societies used to do -- leave the conquered people pauperized and bereft of the bare means of restoring themselves back to respectability and politico-economic health. 

But that is what generally happens when it is brothers who seize a country and fiddle with everything that has given it stability. That fiddling leaves the country wounded beyond measure. There are some historical examples one could cite here, of brothers in the past thinking nothing of playing around with the fate of nations and eventually pushing them over the edge.

Ngo Dinh Diem and Ngo Dinh Nhu were, between 1954 and 1963, brothers who systematically pulled South Vietnam down to misery. Their unbridled corruption, lust for power, and sheer indifference to growing concerns about their behaviour left their country a sordid mess. 

They were unable to contain the growing avalanche of communism as North Vietnam and the Vietcong gradually began to make inroads in Saigon and around it. The corruption of the brothers exasperated their friends in distant Washington, who nevertheless went on sending plane-loads of soldiers to defend South Vietnam from communism. Meanwhile, rumblings of discontent among the South Vietnamese military came to a boil. On November 1, 1963, Ngo Dinh Diem and Ngo Dinh Nhu were murdered as they were ostensibly being led to safety by soldiers who had meanwhile seized power. 

Brothers in power, even if they happen to wield authority in a developed country, raise questions about the morality behind such exercises of power. In 1961, John F Kennedy, assuming office as the new president of the United States, went for the surprising act of appointing his brother Robert F Kennedy as the country’s attorney general.

It was not that America lacked some of the best men in the legal or political fields capable of taking charge of its Justice Department. President Kennedy did not appear too keen on exploring that possibility, but went straight into the business of offering the job to his ruthlessly ambitious younger sibling. 

Prior to the press conference where the President made the announcement about the appointment of Robert Kennedy as the new attorney general, he instructed the latter: “Don’t smile or they’ll think we are happy.” That was a curious statement. One wonders if by appearing serious and unsmiling before all those newsmen they could actually conceal their happiness at being part of the same administration. History informs us that Robert Kennedy as attorney general exercised a good deal more influence on policy-making than any other official, Vice President Lyndon Johnson included, in the administration. 

In 1964, Johnson, elevated to the presidency following the assassination of John F Kennedy in November 1963, was glad to accept RFK’s resignation from the office of attorney general. When the younger Kennedy let his friends know that he was interested in being Johnson’s vice presidential running mate at the November 1964 presidential election, the president pooh-poohed the idea. He picked Senator Hubert Humphrey for the position.

Brothers in politics often strangle a nation into a bad state of health, if not actual demise. That is the image which has, of late, come out of Pakistan, where the brother of a former prime minister has now taken over as the new prime minister following a series of dramatic happenings in the country. Shehbaz Sharif has made sure that over matters of policy his brother, former prime minister Nawaz Sharif will be his regular advisor. The Sharif brothers have never had a record for probity, an attribute they share with so many other politicians in Pakistan. 

Numerous are the cases of questionable financial dealings against them. And yet the brothers remain the recipient of unquestioned loyalty from their followers. They cannot turn Pakistan into a happy country. The rise in prices of food and fuel, the need for loans from the IMF and countries friendly to it, the political instability and the shadow of the army looming over them do not promise a happy future for the brothers Nawaz and Shehbaz Sharif.

But, of course, there are the other lessons of other brothers, those who have not gotten along with one another. When the self-styled Field Marshal Mohammad Ayub Khan ruled Pakistan, his brother Sardar Bahadur Khan served as leader of the opposition in the national assembly. 

The Mughal emperor Aurangzeb would not rest until his more intellectual elder brother Dara Shikoh was defeated in a fratricidal battle, hunted down, paraded in humiliation before the populace, and then murdered. Aurangzeb had Dara’s severed head brought to him. Not a bit of remorse was there in him about his barbarous treatment of his sibling.

Brothers in politics together or simultaneously aspiring to power are a toxic mix, as dangerous as political dynasties attempting to foist themselves on societies. The Rajapaksas are the most glaring instance in these times of how families, seemingly entrenched in politics and blissfully ignorant of ground realities, leave citizens hungry and angry before they go on the run.

Think back on the brothers John Foster Dulles and Allen Dulles in America of the Eisenhower era. Their hawkish positions in politics promoted the Cold War, a phase that was to turn global politics into a dark, ceaseless competition on the part of Moscow and Washington for influence all the way from the 1950s to the early 1990s.


Syed Badrul Ahsan is a journalist and biographer.