We are in a devastating flood for the third consecutive time in some parts of the country. Nature seems to be bent upon testing the resilience of our people, pushing them to their limits.
Our government is doing its best to provide succour to people in distress covering a vast part of our north eastern, central, and northern districts. It has been reported in the media that relief activities at the non-governmental level are considerably larger in magnitude compared to government efforts. It is heartening that people from home and abroad are responding to the call of humanity and trying to stand beside the distressed to the best of their ability.
While material support is forthcoming and spontaneous, coordination remains yet a big challenge in reaching out to people in an efficient manner during such calamity. There are announcements that relief activities will be controlled by the respective administration at district and upazila level -- and people are instructed to go through them.
Some are of the opinion that all sorts of relief activities must be controlled by the government authority for optimum efficacy. This brings some issues to the fore.
When we refer to controlling, what do we really mean to achieve? The intention could be very noble, to reach all who are needy and to ensure optimum use of resources. But the word control by default may seem to have other connotations.
It may imply that the assigned authority is the only legitimate or empowered entity to decide who should go to which place, with what supplies and how. In the process they are the ones in a position of influence to dictate other agencies in carrying out their work.
If we think logically, we have to accept the limitations of the administration in gathering accurate data, means of transportation etc to reach out to the entirety of the affected population in time. Now if they are trying to impose their authority in dictating various agencies engaged in relief distribution, that way, they would curb their initiative badly and deprive people from getting much wanted relief in places where these are actually needed.
Again, there is a lot of difference between controlling, regulating, facilitating, and coordinating. The difference at times may appear to be blurry and very subtle. If we dig a little deeper, we shall find that the terminologies and our approach in each of these have plenty of differences.
Is it not better that the government coordinates all such activities instead of trying to dictate and control? They can make a priority of their areas, categorize those into:
1) Areas in dire need;
2) Areas relief may be given to enhance people having a stock for a number of days;
3) Areas saturated and hence relief may be delayed up to a fortnight
The local authority may also provide such agencies with other important information like items which are prime requirements, transportation means, requirement of water purification systems, whether or not fodder is required for cattle, special medical needs, etc.
Should we aim to control, regulate, or facilitate? What kind of information should the district or upazila administration offer people who are coming forward to provide relief to the affected?
Instead of making declarations that we shall not allow anybody to die out of hunger or out of treatment, is it not better to give out some tangible data as to which are the places we have successfully reached out to and cared for, which are the places we failed to reach, what commodities are most required, which are the localities already saturated with relief efforts?
These could probably be some of the most useful data and need to be updated on a daily basis.
It may not be possible to reach each and every one affected in one go. This reality has to be accepted in view of our huge population, particularly since such huge areas get flooded within such a short time. Moreover there is no denying the fact that our administration is not having all resources ready, such as water crafts for instance which are a must during such devastating floods. Neither do we have updated data of people and households always handy.
If we agree, identify, and accept that there are people who couldn't be reached as of yet, and that there is scarcity of certain vital items over there, only then can we prepare and reach out to them next time. Or else, let others who are ready with resources reach out to those places, thus meaningfully augmenting government efforts.
The lower we go down the level, the more difficult it may appear to coordinate. There were reports on social media that in some localities, enthusiastic individual relief volunteers faced harsh dealings from the police who warned them to get out of certain areas immediately. In a situation where people are living in so much distress, this sounds rather unkind on the part of the police to have turned away people.
The government agencies working in the flood hit area can be the prime actor in providing relief and at the same time may also remain an active facilitator for other agencies who are keen to help people.
In the aftermath of Cyclone Sidr in 2007, Bangladesh saw the largest relief operation ever involving huge coordination among various ministries and a large number of agencies including our own armed forces and a few thousand members of US marines working for months.
There were great instances of coordination both at macro and micro level. We can always draw from such experience to ensure that we don’t falter.
Brig Gen Qazi Anbidus Samad, ndc, psc (Retd) is a freelance contributor. Email: showkat1959@gmail.com