The correct corporate income, or profit, tax rate is zero. That's our starting point for considering the current debate over whether listed companies should pay 20%, or 22.5%, or 25%, depending upon whether they conform to one or other of the desires of the politicians.
For the politicians are attempting to micromanage something that simply shouldn't exist in the first place.
The essential logical starting point here is that all taxes make the wallets of some individuals lighter. An inheritance tax reduces the amount the inheritors have.
An income tax reduces the cash in the wallet of the income earner, and so on. But a corporate tax?
The corporation isn't a living human being, therefore the tax simply doesn't stop there. The study of whose wallets suffer from a corporation tax is called tax incidence.
The usual, and general, agreement is that it's some combination of the shareholders and the workers in the economy who get lower incomes as a result of such a tax.
The shareholders get smaller dividends, or lower capital gains -- that's simple enough. But that they do means that there's less incentive to invest.
It is investment which raises worker incomes by increasing productivity. So, if there's less investment as a result of the tax, then worker incomes will be lower in the future.
That general logical structure is not argued about among economists -- how much falls on which shoulders is. In a rich economy like the US, there are estimates that the corporate income tax is really paid 75% by shareholders, 25% by workers.
Other, equally sensible, estimations have it 25% capital, 75% labour. The exact split is, as we can see, not entirely known.
However, we do know what drives what the split will be.
The smaller the economy imposing the corporate tax compared to the global economy, the more it will be the workers.
Also, the more mobile capital is, then the more it will be the workers.
So, a small economy hoping to attract foreign capital -- foreign capital is at least 100% mobile because it doesn't have to arrive at all -- will be imposing that corporate tax on the workers, not capital or shareholders.
Joe Stiglitz -- who does, after all, have an Economics Nobel -- once pointed out that this incidence can be more than 100%. The losses in the workers' wages can be more than the amount of tax raised.
This is, of course, important. For the political imperative is to say that we're taxing the corporations. But corporations aren't real, live, people, so they cannot carry the burden of a tax.
When we talk about taxing the profits of foreign investors into, by global standards, small economies like that of Bangladesh, then we're really saying that we want to reduce the workers' wages.
This is not a known to be desired outcome of any rational economic policy. So we shouldn't do it, then.
The correct corporate income tax rate is zero, therefore.
All these discussions of 2.5% off the rate for doing this, another similar sum for doing that, they're icing on a logical cake that shouldn't exist in the first place.
Of course, we don't actually want the investors, the capitalists, to live tax free. That wouldn't pass any sensible political test.
What we actually desire is that investment be tax free -- so that there's more of it, which then raises the workers' wages -- but that the rich people aid in paying for the rest of society.
Even Adam Smith thought that taxation should be progressive. This leaves us with something of a problem.
There is an answer to this though. Which is that we leave the returns to investment to be tax free. Corporations aren't taxed, nor are dividends, nor capital gains. But only if they are reinvested.
So, make a profit as an investor and invest that profit back again, then there's no tax to pay. But if that income is taken and used as, well, income, then tax has to be paid upon it.
This is known as a “progressive consumption tax” and is, by the standards of economics at least, the best way to deal with the varied problems.
We don't want the rich living tax free, yet we'd like to maximize investment in the economy.
That answer being tax the rich when they take money to spend but not either what they invest or the profits from having done so.
Which leaves us with just the one big problem. There's no way at all that this is an acceptable political solution.
Which leaves us just with that usual observation that it's politics that stops us from being able to have good economics – politics that stops us from being as rich a nation as we could be.
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London