THE LAST WORD BY TIM WORSTALL

Will cost of tackling climate change rise over time?

A usual part of the current shouting over climate change is that we must, just must, do everything right now. 

It'll be cheaper, do you see? 

The truth of this claim is that it is not true.

This is not the same as saying that we should do nothing, nor is it an attempt to say that the whole thing doesn't matter. But the insistence that everything, right now, will be cheaper is wrong. 

This is so even if we accept that the damages that climate change will do continue to rise as we delay doing something about it. 

For the grand truth is that – in two different ways – delay will reduce the costs of action. 

We face then something of a balancing act to work out whether the reduced costs of action outweigh the reduction in damages that come by doing it all sooner.

One part of this is the difference between the William Nordhaus version and the Nick Stern one.

It’s worth recalling that the first of those two got the Nobel for his climate change work. 

The gap between Nordhaus and Stern is about something called the capital cycle. We've got a number of things already built that we're using. We're also going to have to replace them at some point. 

To work against the capital cycle is to say that we've got to pull all those things down right now. The coal fired plants for example. Kill them and put up solar instead. That’s the Stern version. 

To work with the capital cycle is to say that the coal plant will have to be taken down in 20 years anyway. Or at least we'd have to completely gut it and redo it around then anyway. So why not use the coal plant until its service life is over, and then put up solar? 

Use what we've already built until we need to replace it anyway.

The second reason that delay might be cheaper is that technology is still marching on. One obvious example is solar power. It has been declining in cost at 20% a year for decades now, and there's no evidence that this is going to stop. 

Over the last decade the cost of solar installation declined by 90%. Clearly it's cheaper to install solar in 2021 than it was in 2011.

Or take something a little more uncertain. 

Some insist that aviation must stop. Others, that it must be reduced vastly in size. Or that we must have battery-operated planes (never going to work for long distances) or airships, or – well, or. 

Or perhaps we'll have green hydrogen, something we can definitely make if solar becomes cheap enough. From there making carbon neutral aviation fuel is simple, even if mildly expensive.

So, what's cheaper? 

We don't know yet, but we will in a few years. Kill off aviation or make synthetic jet fuel? Waiting to find out might well be a good idea.

The insistence that doing everything about climate change right now is the best course of action could, theoretically, be true. 

As it happens it isn't. 

Partly because we simply don't know how some of the technologies are going to turn out. We don't know, therefore, whether a choice we make today will be the right one. 

Partly because throwing away perfectly good power plants right now is extremely expensive. Cheaper, by far, to run them until they fall apart – perhaps accelerate that date by overusing them now as Britain did with its coal plants – and then replace them with the right new tech.

So why is there this insistence that it all must be done immediately? 

One reason is undoubtedly that some are all fired up here. Here's this threat to civilisation itself, who wouldn't want to do everything right now? 

Then there's the more cynical observation, which is that some want to use climate change as an excuse to change society. 

Possibly to a less capitalist version, a less market-based one even. 

It's not difficult to see that desire in at least some of the campaigners. So, demand is that everything must be done now to help along that change. Rather than developing new technology that allows the same old system to continue but in a way that doesn’t boil the oceans. The idea being to change the system, not just cure climate change.

Now, yes, that is cynical and I am indeed a cynic.

But then when it comes to proposals for political policies the only really relevant question is: "Am I being cynical enough?"

 

 

Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London