Hefazat means security, protection, safety etc. Therefore, linguistically, Hefazat-e-Islam means protection of Islam.
Before actually protecting something, shouldn't it be ascertained whether or not protection is, in fact, required?
Since the Hefazat group found it necessary to raise their voice in Bangladesh, we need to examine if Islam is endangered in Bangladesh, and if so, who endangers it.
A very accurate determination of state and cause is absolutely necessary. We need to thoroughly analyse the threat to Islam, and if it does indeed exist, devise ways to protect the religion.
An examination of the matter will reveal that a furore was created hurriedly and without much thought, as a political machination that may or may not have been devised to benefit a certain group. Unfortunately, it has apparently helped those that utilise Islamic fervour to their benefit and thereby exploit Islam.
Islam is a vast religion that is all encompassing in the life of a Muslim. Islam guides a Muslim in all facets of his/her life – individual, communal, societal, national and international, personal and impersonal.
A Muslim’s life from birth to death, from head to toe, is completely enveloped by Islam. Where is the space to do otherwise, more so if things are done in the name of Islam?
In no way is a Muslim ever outside the purview of Islam. There is absolutely no separation or distinction between religion and state in Islam as many would like to think, and often choose to propagate. An overwhelmingly Muslim majority country like Bangladesh, by democratic definition or norm, is an Islamic country, whether or not it is named as such.
In a democracy everything goes by the majority, it is the basis for this form of government. However, democracy does not exclude consultation and discussion with the minority and even in Islam we see the tendency to do things in consultation with others. Even if a decision made by such means is wrong, there is no penalty for that.
There is a large number of Muslims who have mistakenly taken “Lakum Dinukum waliya din” (To you be your Way, And to me mine – Sura 109: 6; al-Quran) in its literal meaning without reference to context as “yours is your religion, and mine is mine” taking it to mean religion is an individual matter and an individual is free to practice as s/he pleases. However, the above verse starts with addressing the deniers of faith, “Ya aiuhal Kafiruna (O ye that reject Faith).”
It is collectively addressing the rejecters of faith saying that your faith is yours and our faith is ours. In no way does it refer to one person in relation to another.
To exercise Islam at all spheres of our lives in no way hinders our exercise of equality of other faiths. As secularism does not mean no-religion, and instead refers to the equality of all faiths there is no clash between Islam and secularism, as Islam does not preclude secularism.
Therefore, the perceived threat from "secularism" is a concoction of those who want to derive benefits out of dividing the nation.
Clearly, if something could really be coloured as anti-Islamic, it would be despised by the innocent faithful Muslims of Bangladesh, and would not have to involve any deep indoctrination into Islam. There is no need to be deeply knowledgeable to be pious.
The ritualistically "faithful" beings in our nation are easily inflamed by any disrespect to their religion, whether it be perceived, real or conjured. It is ok when they are faced with real abuse like the Dutch or the American case but it is unfortunate and condemnable when it is a situation where these folks are taken advantage of and told to think of something as un-Islamic. It is an absolute disregard of Islamic cannons. The perpetrators’ sins are multiple as they spread lies, exploit the innocent and become the cause of loss of lives and property. This is a great disservice to the cause of Islam, in the name of Islam. Protest we must, but not violently, and never at the cost of lives and property.
Can a person or a small group of people endanger Islam? Absolutely not! However, they can blemish, besmear, abuse and vilify Islam and that is not to be tolerated. There is no need to raise a false alarm, shouting Islam is in danger and sending a wrong signal to the faithful and instigating violence.
Hefazat's rally was comparatively very peaceful and we must praise the organisers for that. Nevertheless, the very name was a misnomer for there was nothing that could have endangered Islam in Bangladesh, the proof is in the size of the crowd that gathered added to people across the board – the overwhelming Majority in our country that are avowed Muslims. If all these people practise Islam in their lives how can it be in danger? If Islam is deeply ingrained in our lives how would it ever be under threat? Protest rallies and agitation will not strengthen Islam, but practice will.
The madrasas that impart religious education are doing a very important job, but the infiltration of vested interest groups that indoctrinate innocent children in their ideology are creating zombies by doing away with their judgment of right and wrong.
These indoctrinated persons could tell you to your face and to your extreme agony, that actions committed during the Liberation War are normal in a war! And, divested of their own sense of right and wrong, they would believe it too.
However, since the madrasas are educating children that would otherwise remain completely illiterate, we cannot close them. We need to ensure that vested interests are kept out of all of our educational institutions, and that a better mixing of the mundane and the spiritual occurs, to ensure a sense of belonging in the madrasa students. Thus the threat of them misinterpreting Islam and putting it into a bad light can effectively be checked.