There's a basic division when people consider planning the economy. There are those who think that the government can have good ideas about what to do and clearly, it has the power to get them done. So, we'll be better off if we give the power to the government to shape and to plan our economy.
Then there are those like me who think that, while the government can occasionally have a good idea it's unlikely. Further, if we give the government the power to direct the economy then it's us who will find ourselves being directed -- not the point of the enterprise at all to my mind.
This is one of those arguments which depends upon the prior viewpoint. It's very rarely going to be possible to bring in evidence to change minds one way or the other.
However, it is possible for me to switch my example to make matters much clearer. The private, unplanned sector kills mistakes much better than the government does. Whichever system we use, public or private, to try to come up with new things, we know that a few or more of those ideas will be wrong. Wrong in the sense that they don't work, or that no one wants them. We want those non-successes to stop as soon as we realize that they are non-successes. This then, of course, allows us to go try some other things which might succeed.
At which point stands Bangladesh’s jute industry. As this newspaper reports, there's currently some shouting going on about the mandatory use of jute for chicken feed bags. Those who actually packaged chicken feed say it's a very silly idea indeed. It's more expensive, gives the feed a shorter shelf life, and carries significant risk -- through mold etc -- of killing the chickens. They don’t want to have to use it.
So, why is the government mandating that it be done?
Because the government has this idea that jute, in and of itself, is a good thing. I have actually met the minister for jute (hmm, some time ago, so possibly “a” minister of jute) and he was a perfectly sensible chap. But it is proof that the government is looking at this from the wrong end of the telescope. The thinking is that substantial numbers of farmers gain some revenue from producing raw jute. Bangladesh has jute mills left over from when jute was a world beating product and many still work in them. So, we must encourage jute usage to keep the workers, the mills, and the farmers employed.
But jute is yesterday’s item. It is, as is said, more expensive and worse than more modern materials. So, we should stop using it. The farmers should be growing something else, the workers doing something else, and the mills used for something else. That’s how we all become richer, when the assets of the nation are applied to higher value items.
But that's just not how the government sees it. Which is why we get the insistence that jute must be used. The private sector would have killed off the use of jute. We can prove that by that very fact that the government must force its use.
Which is our lesson for today. The private sector marches to the drum of what makes a profit. This means an insistence upon what is efficient. Efficient for this task in the right here and right now. There was a time when jute was that solution -- now it's not. So, the private sector stops using it. It's only the government that insists upon continuing to use the old thing which is now the mistake.
Or, as we can also put it, the private sector kills mistakes where the government does not. The government is more likely to first subsidize then insist upon the mistakes.
Which brings me back to that first idea: Should we be using the government to plan things or leave the private sector to itself? When I first laid it out the come-on was that the private sector will be better at deciding what to do. This second way of discussing the same question is that the private sector kills mistakes faster than the government does. Which might be a stronger argument really -- because we know that both sectors will make mistakes for both are composed of humans like you and me.
But here the argument becomes simple. The argument against government planning is simply to observe what they do plan out. It’s currently the law in Bangladesh that chicken feed must be sold in jute sacks. Jute, which is more expensive and worse. And, you know, if they can’t get something simple like this right then why are we asking them to solve climate change, plan the entire economy, and also liberate women from gender discrimination?
If the easy things are already beyond them, then why even ask about the difficult ones?
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London