Can we escape the God wars?

South Asia is being battered by the politics of religion.

Buddhist monks commit genocide by burning, looting and killing in the name of their god, expelling Rohingya Muslims out of Myanmar. Nobel laureate Aung San Suu Kyi, the darling of Western democracy, remains mainly silent. She finds time though to praise “her father’s army.” Meanwhile, the 969 movement brands the Rohinyas as alien Bengalis to justify the slaughter.

Pakistanis elect a Muslim League leader, amid an election that is not unusual for atrocities, killings and bombings. The rarity is that there is a second election. Nonetheless, in the grander scheme of things, these elections are playing second fiddle to what is happening next door, and in the badland border provinces. There, they prepare to witness the impending victory of the ultra-extremist Taliban forces as the bulk of the neo-colonial NATO armies cut and run from Afghanistan next year.

The Hindu, fascist Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) gear up for elections in early 2014. The prospects of a Prime minister Narendra Modi, infamous for the butchery of 2000 Muslims in Gujarat in 2002 should fill people with dread. The permanent quasi-religious war that is Kashmir, garrisoned by half a million Indian troops, is a slow burning fuse that never wants to go out. 

Despite all the talk of modernity, development and progress, 1947 has left an indelible mark on South Asia. Religion just will not let go of politics in the sub-continent. The Bangladeshi story

In response to the trials relating to 1971, a by-product of 1947, we have seen two remarkable movements surface this year. The religious uprising or challenge to the state in Bangladesh is undoubtedly being assisted by the petro-sheikhdoms, via their sub-continental partners.

Jamaat was born in the western half of the region and there lies its heartland. However much it tries, it cannot grow its roots on Bengali soil.

Or, can it?

For cultural, political and social reasons, the concept of Jamaati-Islamist politics should have been dead and buried in the 1970s. But it did not disappear. That historic failure was due to Bangladesh’s first regime focusing on the wrong enemy - the grassroots left.

As a consequence, it pardoned the collaborators and failed to draw a line over 1971. The right-wing elements of the military then followed the logic and rehabilitated them to the satisfaction of the US and the petro-sheikhs.

A generation later, some wonder if the “new Islamists” are a viable alternative for the majority population in villages, small towns and slums or basties of the major cities? Political forces seek spaces in which to grow. A current of thought suggests that the subalterns feel abandoned, ignored and used by a callous elite.

It suggests they find the anti-establishment message of the Islamists attractive because no one else takes up their plight. I do not subscribe to the narrative that the “Bengali masses” are preparing to accept a theocratic state anytime soon.

I do believe though that people are angry. This deep-seated feeling needs a vehicle for expression. The parasitic political parties, or family businesses, are disconnected and do not speak for the majority.

In a region accustomed to scoring own goals, the real tragedy would be to continue abusing the subalterns.There is a limit and this decade will be it.

Where is the secular option?

If Shahbagh was the firing of a starting pistol and an invitation to build a new construct, what will that be?

Let us start with what it will most certainly not be. It will have no purchase among the majority, if it is a system where garments owners sacrifice all to keep making money. Where Western or Indian energy companies can sign secret contracts with “democratic leaders” and yank out gas and coal at rock-bottom prices. Where poor farmers are left to rot as they are given no chance to make a living.

Where the new urban “Precariat” or slum-bastie millions sleep in appalling conditions after a grueling day of building or servicing the shining towers of a glass-fronted metropolis.

This is not a secular vision that will gain traction. Another one has to be created. This is where the post-Shahbagh movement, that will emerge, has its work cut out.

It has to promote an idea that includes the garment workers, not just the bosses. Feminism has to cross class barriers. Industrialisation has to include the interests of the semi-skilled.

“Bengali” nationalism is toothless if it does not make a stand over national resources. Adibasis and so-called minorities have to be respected, listened to and included. In the upper class imagination, villages have to stop being a holiday home for Eid, and become the centre-stage for massive job creation. If they cannot find a job there, they are going to be your new next door neighbour in the slum across the road.

There has to be dialogue between the progressive elements of the middle class and the Precariat that is already here.

A city master plan that has no permanence, security or space for millions of slum dwellers is nothing but a land grab.

That is the vision of the Narendra Modis where religious triumphalism is tied to capitalist growth. Capitalism and institutionalised religion are best friends. Pogroms, always in the slums, are acceptable as long as property prices go up.

Deceptively, the religious forces over here, while bankrolled by oil and gas, and led by magnates, publicly espouse a more modest message. 1971 prevents them being triumphalist.

Last, but not least, there were significant pro-Shahbagh demonstrations on the streets of Kolkata, Guwahati and Agartala. There lies the opportunity to broaden the arena by strengthening cultural and political links with progressive forces there.

This includes showing solidarity with the Rohinyas. The road to Mandalay is currently clogged up with a cold, chauvinistic nationalism. That has no truck with a progressive nationalism. 

Farid Bakht is a Freelance Contributor.