OP-EDPowered by Froala Editor

What economists mean when they talk about luxury goods

If we should have a conversation about matters environmental then by all means, let us have a conversation about matters environmental. So to respond to Iftekhar Iqbal, who was responding to me who was riffing off his piece and so on in delightful recursion.

The major problem we have here is that there are certain terms of art used within economics when discussing matters. Just as with any other specialization, words are taken to have specific meanings which may often differ from the more generally understood ones used in normal conversation. 

For example: "A clean and sustainable environment is not a luxury item, it is existential -- not only for future generations, but also for us too, now and here."

When an economist says that something is a luxury item he does not mean that it's one of those nice things to have, like a fur coat, or decent handbag, which are only available to the rich. There is a very specific and technical meaning here. 


Also Read - In response to Tim Worstall’s ‘What the Kuznets curve means for Bangladesh’


When incomes change, does the portion of income spent on something change? Do we, in the face of these income changes, now spend a different percentage of our income on these things? If we spend a smaller percentage as our incomes rise then this is an inferior good. If the same percentage then it's a normal good, if a higher portion then it's a superior or luxury good.

When an economist says that a clean environment is a luxury item he means that we will -- entirely naturally -- spend more on having a clean environment as we get richer. That's also all that is meant -- there are no implications at all about whether this is some frippery to be thought of as just a luxury, nor the idea that this is something unimportant that we can do without. "Luxury" has this technical meaning. Richer folk spend more of their income on it.

This then explains why London had appalling smog for centuries and then didn't. London -- Londoners -- got rich enough that they were willing to spend more on heating and energy provision. That meant that the local burning of coal was phased out and so the smog disappeared.

It is this meaning of “luxury" that drives the environmental Kuznets Curve as well. We can see, observe, that richer places are cleaner places. Better air, better water, less general pollution. Why? Because richer people are willing to devote more of their incomes to having those things.

There is also this: "The argument that the environment gets better once people become rich was debunked long time ago through what environmental economists call "Jevon's Paradox," which suggests that the cleaner environment that follow economic prosperity (hypothetically) creates more efficiency in production and consequently put more pressure on natural resources and the environment."

Ah, no. Again a technical point. The Kuznets Curve is about outputs from the system. The Jevon's Paradox is about inputs into it. These are entirely different concepts and they cannot be equated to each other.

Moreover, the Jevon's Paradox contains a very important "maybe" in it. It is possible that increased efficiency will lead to more use of the thing we're now using more efficiently. It's also possible that it won't. Whether it will or it won't depends upon the price elasticity of demand. Which is just a fancy way of saying how much does the use of something change when connected to changes in price of that thing. The Paradox is that sometimes -- maybe, sometimes -- more efficiency leads to such a reduction in effective price that usage rises. 


Also Read - What the Kuznets curve means for Bangladesh


It's absolutely not always and inevitably so.

These technical distinctions are important more generally. We all agree that the economy must be sustainable, that preserving, improving even, the environment is a worthwhile goal. The only arguments are about how that is done. Within such discussions there are technical terms used, ones which have very specific meanings within the field of economics. Trying to disprove an economic argument by ignoring those technical meanings and substituting the more commonly used ones just does not work, I'm afraid.

For example: "Besides, well-known environmental problems associated with industrialization, like the stinks and smog in London, did not disappear after Londoners got rich. Situation improved because of many environmental legislations and their implementation."

The identification of the Kuznets Curve, of the environment as being a luxury good, isn't an argument either for or against environmental regulation at all. It's an argument about when. When is a society rich enough that people will be willing to devote that larger portion of their income to having a cleaner environment?

If you misunderstand the technical jargon, then I'm afraid the actual arguments being made will remain something of a mystery.


Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London