The state has a duty to protect its citizens and it is this responsibility that gives the state the right to use force as it deems necessary.
However, in Bangladesh, safety is never a priority and it seems that most people have accepted this. During any political meeting there is no guarantee that the lives or property of citizens will not be harmed.
People have just accepted the idea that they must just stay home and shut down their shops, schools, and offices - so that political parties can carry out their activities.
On May 5, when Hefazat-e-Islam gathered at Shapla Chottor, many of us around the city stopped our lives and dropped our appointments so that we could be at home safe and sound.
This is because we have little faith that political groups will act in a civilised manner. Amidst this uncertainty we, the citizens, were glued to the news. Messages from concerned friends and families enquired about our whereabouts and safety.
We cringed in fear and uncertainty about the outcome of the protests as we began to see the centre of the city set ablaze and torn to pieces.
I was amazed to find out that a lot of the protestors brought to the rally by Hefazat were, in fact, young students of madrasas.
I doubt that they fully understood the cause of the protests or the real reason they were there in the first place.
Ironically, even the leader of their movement failed to turn up.
Then the chaos began. Shopkeepers were wailing on live television that their stores had been burnt.
The Baitul Mukarram market was set ablaze and numerous Qurans were burnt in the process. I do not know what others felt at that point but to me that violation was just out of order. That was just not right.
These people claiming to be Muslims and using the religion for their political purposes were, in fact, harassing and terrorising the nation.
To me they were not Muslims; they were just goons. How could they destroy the livelihoods of poor street vendors, loot shops, banks, and houses and then use religion to defend their actions? How could these people be Muslims?
More importantly, being a woman, I cannot tolerate and support these extremists, knowing fully well that their demands simply aim to deny Bangladeshi women of some basic rights.
How could I feel safe in my own country when the 13-point demand of Hefazat is even being debated? They reminded me of a failed state like Afghanistan. I shivered at the thought of the progress made by Bangladeshi women over the years being undone in one fell swoop.
As the evening progressed, the so-called peaceful protests turned the area into a war zone. I was concerned for the safety of the citizens and for my Bangladesh.
She was drowning, yet again, in another atrocity where the citizens had little control or say over the actions of these chaotic forces.
What could the state do in this situation? During the early hours of the morning of May 6, they took action, the situation was brought under control when the law enforcement agencies took action and started dispersing the Hefazat followers who had earlier stated that they would stay till their demands were met.
A number of lives were lost in the process of bringing order back to the city. But then began the outcry and social media debates about what could have been a better strategy.
Last month the state had allowed Hefazat to hold peaceful protests. However, in this instance I appreciate and applaud the state’s decision to put an end to the chaos and vandalism that took place on May 5.
In principle, I do not support the taking of lives to establish law and order. But on this day, I have to side with the state. Later when the state also removed the Gonojagoron Moncho, this made me happy as well. It is comforting to know that my state does not allow extremism in any form.
The state will perform its duty as it sees fit. We do not always know better, even though we may think that we do. It is not the citizens’ duty to protect themselves; but rather the state’s. At times we have to leave it to the state to decide what it deems best for the collective.
Sanjana Sadique is a lawyer.