Apathy versus altruism

The dictionary meaning of apathy is “lack of feeling or emotion” or “indifference.” The dictionary meaning of altruism is “unselfish regard for or devotion to the welfare of others.” Some writers and social scientists fear that in a modern, industrial society, as people become busy with the hectic pace of life, they also become apathetic.

Some writers have claimed that the modern condition makes people fragmented. In many urban centres one can, in fact, notice a higher sense of individualism and apathy. On March 13, 1964 in Queens, New York as a young woman was on her way home from work late at night, she was stabbed twice by the same assailant.

This young woman’s name was Kitty Genovese. She parked her car some 20 feet away from her apartment and was walking towards her gate, and a man came out of a dark corner and stabbed her. People watched her being attacked but no one came to help her.

In fact, no one even called 911. The young woman died from her wounds. This incident created a new term, the “Genovese syndrome” which refers to people’s apathy or lack of concern.

The Kitty Genovese event triggered a public discussion about apathy in America. Politicians and policy makers debated over the issue and many were ashamed of how modern America had reached a point where apathy had become the order of the day.

A similar tragedy that seemed to show a complete lack of human emotion happened in Foshan in southern China’s Guangdong province in October 2011. A two-year old girl was run over by a car and as she lay bleeding on the road, people passed by without helping her or even really taking a second look. The little girl was run over a second time before she was rescued and taken to hospital in critical condition.

This incident was caught on tape and went viral on social media. The footage led to some serious soul-searching for all of the 1.3bn people in China. Have people in China become so selfish and indifferent in the mad rush for economic success? It seems that self-reflection in China continues to this day at various levels of society.

In the recent tragedy of Savar, a Dhaka suburb where an 8-storey building collapsed because of shoddy construction and a gross breach of safety rules, ordinary people rushed in to help others. These well-meaning and courageous civilians took great personal risks to help rescue the victims alongside the fire brigade and army personnel who made up the rescue team. The only redeeming aspect to this great tragedy was the selflessness and total devotion to the safety and welfare of others - in a word altruism.

There is no shortage of villains in Bangladesh. But it is good to see some heroes every once in a while. Heroes who deserve our respect. As we mourn those who lost their lives in the Savar tragedy and demand punishment of the culprits, I also salute the heroes who were willing to forgo their own safety and rose to the occasion to help others.

With the help of modern electronic media, we were also able to witness the rescue operation and all the follow-up discussion and commentary on live TV. We all became virtual bystanders of this tragedy. The question is: should we just remain bystanders? Shouldn’t we do something about it?

We, those who live as expatriates in other countries have a choice. Either we can use this as an excuse to settle political scores, endlessly analyse who did what and why and what should be done, and so on, or we can do something truly meaningful. We can vent our anger at the useless discussions and enjoy our “holier than thou” attitudes; or, we can do something positive. We can go beyond just rhetoric and spring into action.

In the true spirit of altruism, we can commit ourselves to help the families and children of the victims.

There are many workers who left behind elderly parents who were dependent on their children who worked at the garment factories in that collapsed building. There are many children who have become orphans. One can think of a big fund raising event or something else which would be just a stop-gap measure, a temporary solution. I suggest a more sustained program of assistance such as long-distance adoption of the school-going children of the victims who can be provided with educational and subsistence support. This can be done privately and quietly without much ado.

Once we start such acts of altruism in our own humble ways – without publicity and media attention – we will find many worthy causes to provide our support to.

Psychologists, after decades of research, now make a distinction between happiness and authentic happiness. They have found that happiness is temporary.

In fact, some psychologists studied people who won lotteries and remained happy for only a few months; after that point their happiness returned to where it was before they got so lucky.

In order to achieve true or authentic happiness, one has to exhibit a real commitment to selflessness. Helping others is not just a good thing, it is also a way to achieve happiness, an authentic happiness that lasts.

Dr Habibul Haque Khondker is a Professor, Department of Humanities and Social Sciences, Zayed University, UAE.