OP-ED: Good luck, West Bengal

Central Park is very close to a location I visit in Salt Lake, Kolkata. Due to my passion for running in the mornings, I often go to this beautiful paradise park at dawn if I visit Kolkata. One morning, after coming back from the park, I overheard the exchange of greetings of the morning walkers and those sitting on the bench of the park. From what I could gather, they were lamenting the fact that Bengalis had a hectic lifestyle that left no room for the indulgence of a jogging habit. 

In another conversation with a friend, the Modi government at the centre came to power for a second term. Looking at the trend of West Bengal, it seems that the BJP has built popularity here as well. What is the reason for the rise of the BJP in West Bengal? He was frustrated that Bengal hadn’t been able to keep up with the pace of industrialization that has happened in Gujarat, and therefore had no political clout.

In the first 20 years after the formation of the National Congress in 1885, seven out of 18 Indians who held the post of president were Bengalis. Subhash Chandra was the last Bengali to be remembered for his all-India leadership. A few days ago, the poet Shankha Ghosh passed away. One by one, the other elder stars of art and culture are leaving this Earth. The heart is getting heavy. After their departure, the short biography published in the newspapers shows their roots are with Barisal, Rangpur, Faridpur, Noakhali, Bikrampur. Suchitra Sen of Pabna, Geeta Dutta of Faridpur, and RD Barman, the list goes on.

For decades now, it hasn’t been easy to find a Kolkata-origin name in education, art and culture at the national level. After Jyoti Basu or Somnath Chatterjee’s passing, there is no hope that the new leadership from Bengal will ever come to light again at all-India politics. Even in the 90s, the younger generation used to wake up listening to Sumon, Nachiketa, and Anjan Dutt. They worship innumerable role models like Acharya Prafulla Chandra, Rabindranath, Jagadish Chandra Bose, Satyen Bose, Satyajit Ray, Amartya Sen, Pandit Ravi Shankar, Mrinal Sen, Shambhu Mitra, and so on. These names began to be forgotten in the greed for capitalism or the intense desire for an all-India identity. Be that as it may, those considered as the voice in the 90s or early 20th century are divided. 

Throughout the ages, artistes have risen above religious narrowness and spread the light of humanity. I heard a long time ago that Mithun Chakraborty paid the cost of sending some Muslims to Hajj every year. The behaviour of any film star admired by Bengalis, including Bangladesh, is now considered shocking to the current political hardliners.

West Bengal is no longer a preferred location for white-collar job for young corporates. I have seen many of this generation are not aware of the glorious contribution of Bengalis to the various achievements of British India or modern India. Even if they are, it is irrelevant to them or this regional pride is seen as an obstacle to their careers. It is not possible to become an Indian without North or South Indian palak ponir or dosa. Our intellectual expressions are taunted as “Bangali aatel,” which is seen as derogatory. 

Not that the Kolkata-based senior intellectuals did not anticipate this situation. Many of them come to Bangladesh as guests at various events during their lifetime and have been overwhelmed by the appreciation and hospitality for their works of art here. Bangladeshis have always been delighted honouring the renowned writers, intellectual, and artistes of Kolkata.

It is not difficult to say how much Visva-Bharati has maintained its identity under the central government. Once, the word Shantiniketan used to evoke a thrill in mind, now it is nothing but a tourist spot for Bengalis. It isn’t easy to see that Visva-Bharati, which was established for multi-faceted education, has played a role in making successful people in recent times in India.

Where the mistake is happening, the identity of nationality or citizenship is constantly changing. There is no conflict between ethnicity and national identity. The attempt to become English during the British period, the effort to become a Pakistani during the Pakistan period, did not last. In the age of globalization, the exchange of culture is a norm. A country combines its identity with a single culture called “Indian culture” because of a map. In Europe and America, many Bangladeshi restaurant owners advertise their offerings as “Indian food.” It is natural for “India,” the “Indian sub-continent,” “South Asia,” to have ethnographic and cultural similarities within these regions. But why the haste to leave Bengaliness and become an “Indian”? Please don’t forget, you have produced the world famous economists Amartya Sen and Abhijit Banerjeee.

Nazbul H Khan is Founder and CEO of PART II, Analyst on South Asian politics.