The Western media was awash with tragic situations during the sudden refugee influx over the past few years. It was inevitable that messing in domestic conflicts by international powers would bring with it such consequences. Perhaps the most poignant visual that caused a quiet outrage worldwide was that of the body of a young Syrian boy, drowned and washed ashore.
It certainly didn’t spur European countries to look again at the issue barring Germany and to an extent, France. They accepted the straggling milieu with an eagerness that would be quick to ebb. Angela Merkel will go down in history as a leader with conscience whose political career was ruined by humanitarian gesture. Debacles in provincial elections for her coalition and an unthinkable resurgence of the far-right, racist ADF was the writing on the wall.
The mistake was that all aspects of housing refugees hadn’t been thought through. And for all her efforts, she couldn’t get the EU to agree on quotas of refugee acceptance or on funds to be made available. Ironically enough, opposing groups included countries that have experienced internal strife and people displacement.
From an essentially neutral perspective, countries that pushed away boats of refugees and enclosed those that slipped through in makeshift concentration camps like hovels were politically and socially correct. Keeping the distance between an unlikely integration and preventing social mayhem appealed to their citizenry. Humanitarianism lost out to the prospect of additional costs for weary economies. That shouldn’t come as any surprise in a world driven by the grind of capitalism and expansionism.
With the media eager to move on to covering events that are of more immediate sensation, the refugee crisis was all but swept under the carpet. Yes, the fires that broke out in two camps were covered. What wasn’t is the aftermath of people losing whatever little they had to begin with. That doesn’t seem to concern Sweden, which has raised a hue and cry over the relocation of the Rohingya to the newly-built Bhashan Char camp.
The concern is that the camp is flood-prone, and connection with the mainland is limited, especially for the NGOs. That there has been no concern raised of the pitiable condition of the current camps in Cox’s Bazar, that disorder is growing, that drug and gun-peddling have become regular incidences, is galling. The Western media is in particular perturbed by what they describe as forceful relocation.
They choose, conveniently, to ignore that the camp cost $364 million to build, including flood-protection embankments built after analyzing 176 years of cyclone and storm surge data. Bangladesh has its own problems, finances not a small element. The camps in Cox’s Bazar are unsustainable -- a grave threat to the environment, of great concern for local citizens, and sealed off after sunset.
The camps at Bhashan Char have decent accommodation, sanitary toilet facilities, schooling in the Rakhine language, and health provisions. There are opportunities for work, in terms of agriculture, animal husbandry, and fishing. That’s a far cry from all the refugee camps in Europe where conditions border on the inhumane, for all the advanced societies there. The world has done little if nothing to help do what the Rohingya want: A return to their homes in Myanmar.
Ursula von der Leyen, the EU president, sounded distant when she said Europe had a limited role to play. Bangladesh has made an effort. Feeding close to a million people every day over more than two years is not a matter to be scoffed at. Assistance in cash or kind has been dwindling, more so after the corona outbreak. Post-Covid matters are likely to become more difficult.
Criticizing an initiative is convenient. Constructive and alternative solutions do not appear to be a priority. The Rohingya tragedy won’t be solved any time soon. Till then, the humanitarian side to it all has been demoted to a “nice to have.”
Mahmudur Rahman is a writer, columnist, broadcaster, and communications specialist.