OP-ED: There are leaders and there are leaders

Jacinda Ardern has shown once again that in these days of all-encompassing mediocrity, good and purposeful leadership is still a shining possibility. She has led her party to a landslide victory in elections in New Zealand and will govern comfortably for three more years. 

Note the absence of hubris in her. She has offered to form a coalition with those not of her party and so reach out to New Zealanders across the spectrum. With a record of firmness behind her, as with her swift handling of the tragedy caused by a maniac shooting into mosques, and with her efficient handling of the coronavirus pandemic, the young Ardern has epitomized leadership as it ought to be.

Ardern has grown in office and is poised to grow even more. But now observe the United States, where the country’s presidency has been dragged into the mud by Donald Trump. Where Ardern reaches out to all her countrymen, Trump has successfully divided them along lines that are bitter and promise to widen the cracks which have already upended life and politics in the country. 

Four more years of Trump, if that dire probability comes to pass, will likely leave America bleeding, resembling all those banana republics we have for years read of, both in fiction and in reality. Trump is a rabble-rouser, happy amidst his fanatical band of followers. He does not represent America as his predecessors did.

One might argue that these are difficult times, which is why leadership everywhere is under strain. That would be a valid point, if you take the havoc being caused by the coronavirus pandemic around the globe into account. The malady has floored societies and left leaders maimed. 

Even so, there are the politicians who have been able to keep their noses above the water. Germany’s Angela Merkel is a good point of reference. France’s Emmanuel Macron tries hard to remain focused on the issues. The good thing about him is that he has not faltered, at least not yet. And then of course there are the authoritarian leaders, Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping, who have kept conditions under control. But is that a surprise? Those who govern through dictatorial tendencies, who have little time for democratic etiquette, are generally providers of strong leadership. Up to a point.

Observe the authoritarian Alexander Lukashenko in Belarus. 26 years in power have not been enough for him. He has “won” the last election, which of course means his followers commandeered the votes that were not cast for him. Here then is a leader who has outlived his time and yet will not walk away into the sunset. The danger about such leaders is that when eventually they stumble and fall, they take a whole society down with them. 

Lukashenko is pushing his country into the gutter, a task which Trump has been carrying out to near perfection. Societies that have mediocre and power-hungry men at the top exist on a knife edge.

But, yes, there is hope even in the pitch dark. It is what the people of Bolivia have just demonstrated through electing the leftist Luis Arce as their new president. Bolivians, with the exception of the rapacious politicians who not long ago conspired to push Evo Morales out of power, have through this election made a couple of things absolutely clear to the world -- that they have not forgotten Morales and that they remember the sound economic policies pursued by Arce when he served as Morales’ finance minister. 

With Arce in office, the humiliation the country’s indigenous population was subjected to by the likes of Jeanine Anez, the woman who brazenly took charge of the country as interim president when Morales was forced out of office, will come to an end. And so Bolivia has a new and proper leader, as Morales was a proper leader. But when you turn your gaze to Pakistan, you instinctively feel an absence of leadership in the country despite Imran Khan’s holding of the prime ministerial office. Bilawal Bhutto Zardari has regularly berated him as Pakistan’s selected, as opposed to elected, prime minister. And he is not too far wrong, given that Pakistan’s ubiquitous military, through its own arithmetic, connived to have Imran Khan take charge, though not all of it, of the government. 

The Muslim League of Nawaz Sharif and the Bhutto family’s People’s Party had their votes stolen at the last election through the sinister work of military intelligence. The point is inescapable: Imran Khan is prime minister, but he is not a leader. Pakistan’s soldiers have historically been uncomfortable with leadership rising from among the masses. They did away with the impertinent ZA Bhutto and the naïve Benazir Bhutto, literally.

There is a very great need for leadership in Thailand, as its young people have been showing for the past so many days. They have braved police intimidation, have prevailed through police water cannons, have defied threats from Prayuth Chan Ocha and his fellow usurpers who have kept the country in their grip for the past six years. They have done the courageous thing of calling for reforms of a monarchy that has consistently regarded any questioning of its legitimacy as lese majeste; and they have demanded the resignation of the government, which is a military regime in reality and which is therefore an anachronism in our times. No leader, of the kind who could lead Thais into the future, has yet emerged. But these young people have shown that leadership does not have to be claimed by coup-makers, and that overthrowing the elected governments of the two Shinawatras, the siblings Thaksin and Yingluck, was a disaster.

There are leaders who grow in office, as West Germany’s Willy Brandt grew in office. There are leaders who begin with promise but soon slip at some point, a good instance being Mikhail Gorbachev. Ronald Reagan may have been a right-wing American ideologue, but he was a president who instilled confidence in his people after all the years of despondence -- defeat in Vietnam, Watergate, and economic recession. His charisma and qualities of leadership have not quite been equalled by his successors. Malaysia’s Mahathir Mohamad was once an assertive leader. And then unbridled ambition, even in advancing age, and vindictiveness toward Anwar Ibrahim, marred his reputation. 

And, yes, leaders all too often come in two packages. Some remain politicians, with all their unwillingness to make way for individuals to take over from them. Some others, really a handful, transcend to the heights of statesmanship through conveying bright visions of the future to their people and at the same time presiding over the growth of new leadership in their parties and in their countries.

One would not be much mistaken in persuading oneself that Jacinda Ardern comes in the second category. 

Syed Badrul Ahsan is a journalist and biographer.