Two recent reports on Bangladesh’s economic situation has caught my attention. One report was about the per capita income of Bangladesh and another on the signs of early recovery from the pandemic fallout. Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (BBS) recently released data that shows the PCI of Bangladesh rose to $2,064 in FY20 from $1,909 registered in 2018-19. Economists of a leading foreign bank, referring to their own research, claimed: “The storm over Bangladesh economy has blown over.”
It is claimed that Bangladesh might be one of only two stand-out economies in the Asean and South Asian region to achieve growth in 2020 amidst the global recession triggered by the coronavirus pandemic. In support of the claim, they used data of foreign remittance inflow and increased export income of the previous month.
There is no denying of this data. Bangladesh achieved 5.24% GDP growth in the previous fiscal year and expects to achieve more than 8% growth in the current fiscal year. Bangladesh amassed an unprecedented foreign currency reserve of $4bn and inward remittances despite the global economic blackout. The Finance Ministry reported, during July 2020 the country received an all-time high monthly remittance amount of $2.23bn. The trend continued from June when $1.83bn remittance was received -- as much as 39% higher than that of June 2019.
These reports and accompanying statistics underline numbers of progress of our economy. The beauty of these magic numbers resides in the possibility of squishing all human activity into a couple of digits. Though used to measure development globally, this condensing is gravely flawed. It ignores convoluted, nuanced, and contested features of humanity and well-being.
The flipside: Vulnerabilities and inequalities
I do not deny that statistics of PCI or inflow of remittances stand for progress of one kind or another. These demonstrate dynamic economic activities and production of values in the country. Numbers do not lie, I agree. But we must be cautious, because these numbers divert our attention from extreme misery, uncertainty, and inequality on the flipside of growth and progress.
For instance, the inflow of foreign remittance increased perhaps because migrant workers are sending back all their savings in fear of deportation. Many are bringing back savings in a rush, being stuck in Bangladesh due to the pandemic and having no possibility of return.
There are other dark sides that do not get attention due to the focus on growing GDP, PCI, or foreign currency reserve -- so to speak. While Bangladesh achieved unprecedented averaged GDP growth of more than 6% over the last decade, we tend to forget continuous rise of inequality over the last 50 years. Measure of income inequality from data of BBS show, nationally Gini has risen from 0.36 in 1963 to 0.482 in 2016.
More data can be referred to indicate the flaws of digits representing development. We are achieving the highest levels of growth, and at the same time, we are experiencing the lowest levels of poverty reduction among South Asian countries. An analysis of BBS data reveals that the rate of poverty reduction has decreased to 1.2% points annually during 2010-2016 from 1.7% points during 2005-2010.
Moreover, ILO Global Wage Report 2018-2019 identified, Bangladesh achieved 3.4% real wage growth in the last 10 years, which is lower than the median growth of 3.7% in South Asia.
In the book The Growth Delusion: Wealth, Poverty and the Well-Being of Nations, David Pilling has argued statistics of growth do not consider an equitable distribution, hence living people are left out of sync. The obsession with growth hides the inequitable accessibility of health, education, security, opportunity, goods, and so on.
Growth versus youth needs
Statistics of progress such as growth in GDP, PCI, remittance inflow alone cannot ensure what people really need and want, if not matched by reduced inequity. Mustafa K Mujeri in a 2018 op-ed asserted, fundamental unequal access to opportunities has increased “geographical, gender-based, and group-based inequalities” in Bangladesh. This claim is supported by the Labour Force Survey (LFS) 2016-17; it revealed, even though the national unemployment rate is 4.2%, youth (age 18-35 years) unemployment stands at 10.6%.
Specifically, youth unemployment rate has risen significantly in the last 20 years. The Asia-Pacific Employment and Social Outlook 2018 of the ILO reported, youth (age 15-24 years) unemployment increased from 6.32% in 2000 to 12.8% in 2017. Additionally, the LFS 2016-2017 found that 29.8% of the total youth population are neither in education, nor in employment, nor training (NEET). Among the youth with secondary level education, 28% remain unemployed as most jobs are created in the informal sector.
For more than one-third of the male youth, unemployment is a major obstacle in life, as the Brac Youth Survey 2019 has revealed. Youth of the country are likely to face harder times finding employment in the future. Bangladesh Institute of Development Studies through one of their surveys identified that 13% people have faced loss of employment since March 2019.
These data indicate that Bangladesh has registered economic growth, but the youth did not benefit from it; they are not even receiving the required skill set. Thus, one may ask whether economic growth is enhancing prosperity or creating multi-dimensional societal strains?
The conditions of the real producers
A look at the front lines of our food supply system reveals signs of grim neglect and inequality. PPRC Governance and Economic Survey 2015 revealed disparity among different segments of the population. For instance: The average monthly income of people in rural areas -- with agriculture as the major income source -- is Tk18,349. The amount is significantly less than the national average monthly income of Tk31,883.
Further, if adjusted for inflation, real income of the rural population has decreased by 9.73% compared to 2012. Overall, in Bangladesh, the average monthly income of the bottom 40% of the population is Tk10,657, whereas for the middle 50% and top 10%, the average monthly income is Tk25,763 and Tk147,388, respectively.
The pandemic has affected agriculture-dependent people severely. Brac revealed that during the 45-day lockdown period between March and May, the country’s farmers faced a loss worth Tk565.36 bn. The amount of loss is unprecedented, but a loss of the farmers is quite common. During every harvesting season, we find news about peasants not getting fair prices while price hikes at the retail market in cities are commonplace. Thus, people involved in the supply chain only gain profits.
If not taken care of comprehensively, the real producers of the country will suffer more and the country’s growth will plummet as the South Asian Network on Economic Modelling has recently projected -- Bangladesh’s poverty rate may rise up to 40.9%, which is two times higher compared to the pre-pandemic rate of poverty in the country.
Highlighting specific numbers of progress divert our attention from the historical predicaments that the pandemic has aggravated and demand our sincere attention.
One may claim, I have picked data that hide the economic progress of the country. In turn, such claims will support my point that emphasizing and targeting one set of data as progress ironically hide the other darker sides. As David Pilling in 2018 has argued, hours of sleep might be “a proxy for work-life balance or stress” which has steadily declined since the 1940s. Thus, it is better to measure improvement through the lens of reduction of miseries.
Mohammad Tareq Hasan is an anthropologist and teaches at the University of Dhaka.