Who’s your reference?

In December 13, the TV channel Ekattor aired a show about brain drain and the future of young people in Bangladesh. In that show, a Bangladeshi woman living in Australia made a comment, underlining a grave social aberration.

The person in question graduated from Dhaka University and then went to Australia to study. She later came back to Bangladesh and, failing to find work commensurate to her qualifications, went back to Australia. Though she feels for her country like countless other expatriates, she is forthright in saying that in Bangladesh, only skill and talent won’t take a person to a deserved position. This observation by an expat in Australia touched chords with many, who thanked her for being candid about an entrenched social anomaly which gets bigger every day.

A few years ago, I was invited to a program arranged by the Dhaka University career club, asked to share career related experiences with the young and impart some advice. There was a person from the media, a colourful, flamboyant character. This person took the stage and took out a Tk100 note and asked: Who wants this note? 

One person ran up to the stage and took the note form the man’s hand. All very dramatic and certainly impressive. Then the media personality pontificated: “In this society, one has to go and get what one wants!”

There was applause in the hall and the young responded with cheerful approval. Interesting and thrilling but hardly the right career advice for youngsters because life’s aspirations are not flaunted for anyone to just go and grab. 

There is the expression: You need a mama, chacha, or khalu to get your talents recognized for work. Maybe these expressions are a bit too crude but what they actually try to prove is that a reference is essential in getting work or called for an interview. The “reference” means someone dropping a positive word on behalf of the applicant and this may be very subtle.

Let me tell you a personal experience. Around 15 years ago, I was trying to get into an international news agency and talked to the agency’s head in Bangladesh. Despite knowing that person, I was told that their policy was to consider someone only with a reference. In simple terms, someone senior in the agency or any other person of influence would have to vouch for me. 

There is an unwritten law concealed under morally correct rhetoric about complete transparency about employment, but of course, the reality is just what the woman said in that TV talk show. 

At that career counselling session, I told the students that they should spend time developing connections, knowing people, and building relations -- in short, building the reference, which is crucial. Several other people did not approve of what I said but then, isn’t it better to tell the young the truth instead of driving them into an unreal realm of fantasy?

Being a journalist, I mix with people from all layers of society and one such employment process showed the vital role money plays in ensuring employment. What is most disconcerting is that people were willing to give over Tk10 lakh to get the job and they did not take the demand for money to be immoral either. 

When I asked one candidate, the response was: “Money is needed for all such work.” It seemed that there is an understanding within society that for certain work, money has to be paid. This is not deemed corrupt or unethical anymore, just part of the system. I have seen people paying money to get work and after securing the coveted post holding a special prayer session to express gratitude to the Almighty. How they reconcile the dubious with the spiritual is only known to them.

Employment procedures at most international agencies in Bangladesh are also not transparent. Maybe they do not deal in “cash” exchanges but a reference still plays a potent role. Then there is another hidden system in which certain jobs are reserved only for foreigners, or to be blunt, the whites. There is an unwritten law that specific posts cannot be given to locals and therefore, these are inevitably given to foreigners.

What is the remedy? With 26 years of experience, I can tell you this: Just don’t go out there with skills and talent alone, develop connections and contacts. Also know, the mama, chacha, khalu connection is applicable not only in Bangladesh but for every country in the world. Pulling a few strings for someone or dropping in a good word works everywhere. 

Talented are those who are skilled at developing connections. Maybe that should be our new year’s resolution. 

Towheed Feroze is News Editor at Bangla Tribune and teaches at the University of Dhaka