The view from the summit

The 50th ASEAN Summit just concluded in Manila, generated renewed momentum to the organisation’s commitment to ensuring development, cooperation, peace, and stability in the region.

The summit reviewed current issues, took note of areas for reconciliation within the region, and emphasised on mutual understanding as well as non-interference in the internal affairs of member countries, from both within and outside the region.

The summit also assessed the impact of policy shifts in the US and Europe and probable adjustments within the ASEAN region to protect its own interests.

Since its establishment in 1967, ASEAN has succeeded in fulfilling its obligations despite critical challenges at times. The group operates with unity and strength despite variations in economic standing.

Pushing ahead with RCEP

ASEAN also stands ahead compared to several other regional and sub-regional initiatives that emerged at about the same time. Members find value in the ASEAN products and outcomes.

This time round, the economic aspects received priority as in the past few summits. The US withdrawal from the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP), Eurozone uncertainties, as well as protectionist economic and external trade policies by some developed countries have propelled the ASEAN countries to push ahead with the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP).

ASEAN first pushed the concept of RCEP in 2012, but it was eclipsed by the TPP, which the then US President Barack Obama had deemed a “progressive deal” that would prevent China from “influencing the rules of world trade.”

Initially four ASEAN members -- Brunei, Malaysia, Singapore, and Vietnam -- were signatories to TPP. However, TPP lost two-thirds of its members’ combined GDP when the US decided to back out.

It also minimised the impact of TPP and signalled the inevitability of RCEP as the key alternative to eliminating barriers and promoting free trade in the region. While the US retains the rights to take action to protect its trade and economic obligations, China has put its weight behind RCEP and finds this a suitable instrument to promote China’s trade within the ASEAN region.

RCEP seems to have emerged as the best alternative to lowering tariffs in the region for Asia’s export-driven economies. A challenge for ASEAN nations would be to have in place new guidelines to comply with the member countries’ common resolve to significantly reduce existing non-tariff measures and barriers to achieve the region’s economic potential.

Reaching goals

ASEAN needs to reduce its non-tariff barriers by at least 50% in order to reach the targeted size of the region’s economy of $9.2 trillion by 2050.

To overcome current stumbling blocks in trade and promote exports, ASEAN countries need to strengthen efforts to bring this down from 4% to less than 1%. However, to what extent RCEP could be effective in this regard remains to be seen.

In terms of harmonising policy frameworks within the region, the sub-regional group of ASEAN (BIMP-East ASEAN Growth Area) continues to focus on massive infrastructure expansion program to boost inter-regional trade and connectivity.

The key challenge is to ensure inclusiveness and sustainability of growth beyond the medium-term

The summit’s decision to focus on underdeveloped regions and support income and employment-oriented programs for greater inclusiveness aims at ensuring sustainable growth in the medium-term.

While five of the 10 ASEAN members are still “developing,” three are middle-income while the remaining two are high-income levels but heavily energy-dependent, and require substantive financial and institutional improvements.

ASEAN’s expansion is further seen based on the increase of collective GDP to about $2.7tn compared to $87bn four decades ago. However, the key challenge is to ensure inclusiveness and sustainability of growth beyond the medium-term.

Failure to do this would lead to risks and further inequalities. Much would depend on each country’s economic policies.

With most of the ASEAN economies growing faster than the rest of the world, ASEAN is expected to meet its target by 2050. In this context, the big challenge is in ensuring the integration of individual economies and the resilience of the ASEAN economies to bear the adverse impact of the Eurozone fluctuations.

The China-Philippines dispute over the ownership of Sparatly islands and oil blocks in the South China Sea (SCS) has been a major issue. The summit agreed to call for peace and security in the South China Sea area and called for reconciliation and negotiations to ease tensions.

Apart from China and the Philippines -- Vietnam, Malaysia, and Brunei also have claims on the SCS. Thailand, a non-claimant to SCS, emphasised the need to finalise a framework for the proposed code of conduct as a binding agreement that will ensure peace and stability through negotiation-led resolution of disputes.

Proposal on the ratification of the Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ), the Continental Shelf Delineation, and the proposed Sea Code should allow for significant improvements in maritime rights for countries of the region. The summit also reiterated a stand against militarisation and further land reclamation in the South China Sea.

Challenges and expectations

The 50th ASEAN Summit has taken place at a time when there is a perceived paradigm shift in US interests in the region. At the same time, the steady social and political transition in Europe, and the India-China relations will be crucial in the upcoming months.

The Post Summit challenge would be to ensure that contentious issues are eased in compliance with decisions per international law. The ASEAN Charter has limitations in enforcement, as so much would rest on how these issues are resolved bilaterally.

The ASEAN Summit’s concerns on the US-North Korea tensions and seeking the support and cooperation of the US to prevent any probable conflict comes as credible and useful regional response to this crisis.

ASEAN expects that the forthcoming dialogue with key partners would enable it to strengthen strategies and policies to better suit the region’s economic interests. In light of this, it could envision broadening partnerships with regional and sub-regional cooperation and integration arrangements.

The summit also discussed the issue of migrant workers, the menace of drug abuse, eliminating trans-border crimes, stronger vigilance against terror, and incorporating elements related to the welfare of citizens of any one of the ASEAN countries working in the other.

Some issues bearing utmost relevance not covered in this summit could be raised in the next summit. These include public financial management and improved governance, improved service delivery to remote areas, and the harmonisation of procedures to further cross-border mobility of goods and services.

There is urgent need to raise the Rohingya issue, for which Myanmar is responsible. The need for further collaboration with RCI arrangements in South Asia and East Asia should also receive attention in subsequent summits.

In the future, ASEAN may consider expanding dialogue to support South-South Cooperation as well as economic cooperation between South and Southeast Asia. It could also open its frontiers to support knowledge hubs to reflect on best practices on areas as infrastructure financing, promoting entrepreneurship, and better access to credit and finance.

These would contribute to improved quality of life and sustained economic growth in the region.

Mohammed Parvez Imdad is a senior economist, academic, and policy analyst. He worked for 35 years in the National and International Civil Service. Currently, he teaches in Manila and works as Senior Economic Advisor based in Manila and Brunei.