A good way to settle

According to WIPO, the arbitration is a procedure in which a dispute is submitted by agreement of the parties, to one or more arbitrators who make a binding decision on the dispute. In choosing arbitration, the parties opt for a private dispute resolution procedure instead of going to court. Therefore, we can conclude that an arbitration process is governed by agreements instead of laws of the court. 

In courts, all national or international laws apply according to the concerns of the placement of the court and provided laws are binding on the parties.

On the other hand, arbitration takes place in forums, either national or international. In arbitration, parties have the privilege of choosing their laws by formatting their own agreement for the matter. 

However, in arbitration, no laws are binding until the parties themselves choose the law. As a result, when the parties have the choice of selecting their governing laws, they frequently try to have an arbitration clause in their agreement briefing the procedure of the matter.

While choosing procedural laws of arbitration in the international regime, parties often become puzzled. The root of such problem is the divisions of legal systems around the world, such as the “Civil Law System” and the “Common Law System.”

These two legal systems affect the nature of public laws, and parties from two different legal systems often try to solve their problems by choosing an institutional forum instead of ad hoc arbitration; an institutional forum applies their own rules. 

Therefore, when parties agree to go for an institutional arbitration, they have to follow an institution’s rules and regulations.

However, parties may come to their own agreement in mentioning the applicable law, and this may affect their expected judgment as the arbitrators might face difficulties interpreting the law.

In many cases, parties fail to incorporate precise arbitration agreements, which do not take particular circumstances of the contract into account.

The P Patocchi and C Jermini Arbitration emphasized the need for a uniform set of rules for recognition and enforcement of international arbitration agreements and arbitral awards. 

Moreover, the Lex Arbitri refers that mandatory provisions imposed by each country on arbitrators in their own territory regarding arbitrability, interim measures, entitlement of the tribunal to rule on its own jurisdiction (known as the doctrine of competence-competence), judicial assistance, rules of ethics, and many others. The choice of law often relates to the public policy and the parties. Therefore, arbitration tribunals fail to circumvent the chosen laws. 

Contrarily, the awareness of the parties while drafting an agreement plays a vital role because any inconveniences may cause economic deficit to the parties. In major cases, the parties show their unwillingness to choose the applicable law because of their lack of legal knowledge and experiences. This involves the parties with an agreement refereeing to institutional forums, as the forums may follow their own proceedings in relation to the dispute. 

In the Fiona Trust and Holding Corp v Privalov Arbitration, the discussion of the choice of law principles begins with the separability presumption, which provides that an agreement is separable from the underlying instrument with which it is associated. Under an interim order, ICC held that, “the presumptive separability of the arbitration agreement, and therefore the possibility that a different law may govern the parties’ arbitration agreement than the underlying contract, is recognized, inter alia, by both New York Convention and the Model Law.” 

Therefore, it can be argued, different laws like the New York Convention and the Model Law may govern an arbitration. So, parties often rely on international instruments rather than choosing a national law.

On the other hand, in a Final Award, ICC held that, “[a]n arbitration clause in an international contract may perfectly well be governed by a law different from that applicable to the underlying contract.”

In another case, the US Court held that, “[a]rbitration agreements relate to the law of remedies, and their enforcement, whether at common law or under the broader provisions of the arbitration acts, is a question of remedy to be determined by the law of the forum, as opposed to that of the place where the contract was made or is to be performed.”

The above-mentioned references interpret as the parties might not always be absolutely perfect in drafting a contract, and it often seems that different laws might serve better remedy to the parties. 

Therefore, arguments can be drawn that parties tend to rely on laws that may ensure proper remedy to the cases and this might drive them away from choosing the agreement laws regarding arbitration and enforcement of the awards.

In conclusion, it can be admitted that the place of arbitration is used as the exclusive criterion in relation to the great majority of national laws.

International obligations and principles provide privileges to the parties, whereas national laws allow parties to choose the procedural law of a state other than that where the arbitration takes place. 

However, because of the lack of legal knowledge and the fear of costs, precedents show that parties in practice rarely use that facility.

Md Asif Mahbub Tanvir is an apprentice lawyer practicing at Dhaka Judge Court, Bangladesh.