Being heard in the workplace

“I know, I know,” my boss replied without even letting me finish. I had been following the market trend for over a week now, and I had a great idea about relocating the niche for our banking product. 

This came from Ania, another frustrated corporate ex-employee from Dhaka. We had this conversation months ago, when she was talking about her first job. The topic came up again when I was inquiring as to why she had left it for a fledgling, no-security start-up in Dhaka.

Ania remembered that she had asked her ex-boss again: “What do you mean you know if I haven’t even explained how the strategy works?” She was insisting.

She told me at one point that the more she tried to talk to her boss, the more defensive and offended he got, and she couldn’t even understand why.

In the beginning, they actually had a great working relationship, because Ania, within months, had already proven business for her boss’s company. She loved working there, as it was an established business. Moreover, as the culture goes, working in a great multi-national company in Dhaka comes with social prestige in the community. She wanted to stay.

“No, No, Ania, I got it, I got it,” said her boss, totally rejecting her help.

Ania asked me, “What did I say wrong, Touhid? Did I offend him in any way?”

I was worried, I was tense. Not for Ania, but for her boss -- he would be losing an excellent employee very soon, just because he was not willing to listen. What I gathered later on was that he had a great relationship with Ania only because she was obedient and followed his orders, since she was a new employee. 

But when she started to understand the organization’s process and suggested improvement, their relationship fell apart.

After the conversation that day, I went back to Germany and then to Rhodes University, South Africa, with a study fellowship. Six months later, I was back in Dhaka and sipping a cup of coffee with Ania again.

For the last three months, she has been happily working in a start-up. It had minimal security as a career choice compared to the multi-national established business before, but she was satisfied. Her voice was heard. She has been an active contributor of ideas that were constantly being experimented with. Some clicked, some didn’t. But what mattered most to her was that her CEO actually stopped and listened.

As I continue to gather experience as a business anthropologist, sometimes I find that the problems and solutions are so simple; but if they are not fixed, they yield to monumental problems later on. Like a small fire in the corner of the house -- if not taken care of, and left unattended, some day it might burn the house down. That is what happened to Ania with her previous company.

When I try to distinguish between the corporate CEO and the start-up CEO, the only difference in the culture code would be: I KNOW. One perceives that one knows everything, and the other doesn’t.

The problem with a successful upper management -- not just CEOs -- is that they have the power to create a world around them, a world suited for their own validation. When you only hear what you want to hear all the time, you close your door for disruption, innovation, and entrepreneurship.

Then there are members of the young generation like Ania, approaching work with a mind-set deeply soaked in entrepreneurship culture. As new employees, they tend to experience a company with fresh eyes, and often have innovative ideas which can either drive the company, for better or for worse. Hence, the success of a CEO should be as a decision-maker; someone who can bet which ideas might go in favour. 

But if you have only seen Toyotas all your life, and someone wants to talk to you about Teslas, and you are not open to innovation, saying, “I know, I know,” and not learning more about Teslas does make sense, but not as an organization.

People and organizations are so intertwined that blindness of this sort is often rationalized in organizational culture, even though these choices are fully emotional. It’s a bias, often termed as Anchoring Bias in the behavioural sciences.

So, what can we do about it?

As people driven by egos, as emotional human beings, you and I don’t appreciate being told by someone what to say or not to say, what to do or not to do. It is even worse for someone to instruct us in something we already think we know all about. Coming from a new employee, it can feel twice as worse.

Therefore, when we need to be sure that a person will come through for you, we can phrase the body language, voice tones, and words in such a way that their ego will not be offended.

You might (in a genuinely encouraging tone) begin with the words, “I know that you …” and then provide him/her with the necessary information.

Here’s an example: “Dear Mr X, I know that you believe in being sensitive to people’s feelings; that’s why I have no doubt you will be especially tactful when telling Mr Y about the mistake he made on that report.”

“Ms Z, I know you already know that the statistics need to be filed in for the presentation. You have a way of always putting these things together correctly.”

“Mr Q, I know that you already know everything about our target market for product X, then you must know about the specific niche which might be more concentrated and yield us more sales in less time.”

After our conversation, Ania has now been using the “you know” anchoring with her new boss and clients, and reports to me that she feels even more heard and responded to.