It is possible for a government to have the right general policy and yet to go about implementing it in entirely the wrong manner. So it is with the Bangladeshi government’s work on the VAT system. It’s entirely correct that VAT is a great way to raise the funds necessary to pay for the work that government does. But for government to go out and buy the actual systems which are used to collect that VAT is entirely the wrong way to go about it.
This is even before we think about the possible shenanigans over who has placed the order with which manufacturer in return for what and all the rest of that depressing but all too common story.
As to why a VAT system -- an essential truth is that if we tax something, we get less of it. Tax apples and there will be fewer apples. Tax incomes and incomes will be lower. However, how much less of something we get depends on the specifics of that particular thing we’re trying to tax.
We also know the general spectrum along which this happens too. A transactions tax -- say a tax on each share trade on a stock market -- has very high “deadweight costs” as they are called. A deadweight being economic activity that doesn’t take place because of the taxation we have imposed.
This is the mirror image of the Laffer Curve idea, where taxes can be so high that cutting the rate will increase the amount collected. Because that very high tax rate was stopping economic activity from happening. We are saying that different taxes have different peals to that Laffer Curve -- the same thing as saying that different taxes have different deadweight costs.
So, we have a spectrum of such taxes and their deadweights. A transactions tax is very high, then a little lower are capital and corporate taxes, lower again are those on income, then lower those for consumption and lowest of all is land value taxation -- or the taxation of resource rents.
Which is why we like a VAT. This is a tax upon consumption and that means its deadweight costs -- what doesn’t happen because of the tax -- are low and we think that’s a good idea. Sure, we need tax to pay for government, but let us do it with the least damage to economic activity. So, having a VAT is a good idea, Bangladesh is right to have one.
Then we come to what the implementation of the tax system. The government has decided that retailers should use electronic tills in order to make monitoring the system simple. These cash registers should then all be tied into the central tax collecting authority’s computers. That’s not a necessary part of any such system, but that’s what was decided upon. And then things start to go wrong.
For the government -- a cabinet committee at least -- decided that it should be the government buying those tills. Which would then be distributed to retailers, who then pay for them over time. No, this isn’t the way to do it at all. Partly I am reminded of what happened in the Czech Republic when exactly the same was done. It’s was the then finance minister’s brother whose company got the job of designing and installing the systems. Funny that he was the one person in the country with the best equipment and prices, isn’t it?
But more than that, by doing this, the government has entirely cut itself off from market competition. As we do all know this being exactly what makes goods and services better over time. We’ve now got the one monopoly supplier of these systems into Bangladeshi retailers and monopolies just aren’t inventive and cost-cutting. Why should they be, they’ve already got the entirety of the market, haven’t they?
Far better would have been for the government to say that, by this specific date -- some couple of years in the future say -- all retailers above a certain size must use electronic tills. These tills must be able to report information to the central tax collection agencies in the one specific format.
After that, leave it to the market to produce, finance, and install the systems. That is, the government simply creates and publishes the interface for the system along with the insistence that it must be used. What equipment, from which manufacturer, is used to produce the data which meets that standard, well, who cares? Except, we know that competing manufacturers are exactly what will produce ever better systems at ever lower prices.
As I said at the top there, the basic strategy is just great. Yes, a VAT system is a good idea. It’s the tactics and implementation that follow from that which are at fault. Government buying and installing computer systems doesn’t have a great track record anywhere while market competition really does work in this field.
Tim Worstall is a Senior Fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.