With a grain of salt

A serious question for the government: Why do we want to be self-sufficient in salt? What is the economic or political reason for wanting to insist that the salt consumed in Bangladesh is produced in Bangladesh? 

For that’s what a recent announcement has left us wondering. Kamal Ahmed Mojumder was at a meeting organized by, among others, Unicef, where he said that there was to be a control on imports of salt so that the country could become self-sufficient. What he didn’t explain was why. Unless, of course, that’s just the sort of thing you say when you’re addressing a number of salt producers. They’ll like the sentiment even if no one else will.

The larger meaning of the meeting was perfectly sensible -- it was about the addition of iodine to salt, and how it would be a good idea to move to a universally iodine added national supply. Yes, certainly, iodine is a vital trace element, and a lack of it produces a swelling in the thyroid called “goitre.” This is also associated with, when it happens in pregnant women, severe mental retardation in the child. 

Actually, the word “cretin” doesn’t just mean the politician you don’t like, it’s a technical term for the sort of congenital idiocy caused by iodine lack. Such iodine lack can be solved -- in fact in much of the world is solved -- by adding a trace to the general salt supply.

Excellent, that’s a good thing to be promising from Bangladesh. By why this extra idea of self sufficiency? In a modern economy that is, there’s certainly considerable historical importance attached to it. The British Raj charged a hefty salt tax, just as one example (as did the Mughals, as also happened in France etc) and there was considerable political opposition to it. 

The reason the tax was charged is because salt is vital to life. Thus you can make sure you get the tax money by adding it to something people simply must have. So, we might have some sort of hangover from that period, whereby people think that producing our own salt is a good idea because of those horrible foreigners.

But other than that, there’s no real reason. Salt’s not in short supply anywhere in the world. Any sunny area near salt water can evaporate salt out of the sea. Which is how Bangladesh’s supply is produced, of course. It’s also possible to mine it -- Himalayan pink salt is most fashionable these days -- for there are the vast remains of evaporated seas lying underground all over the place. 

It’s thus pretty cheap stuff, $80 a tonne seems about the price for solar evaporated material from salt water. And there are literally thousands upon thousands of suppliers out there.

If we were only talking about table salt, then perhaps, well, why not? There’s a lot of ruin in a nation, as Adam Smith pointed out, and there’s room for us to have more than a little bit of economic inefficiency for historic or nationalist reasons. Sure, we should all get asked about it rather than having it imposed upon us but still, why not? 

But here’s the thing, while table salt for addition to food is absolutely vital for continued human existence, that’s not, by any means, the major use of salt. By far the larger uses are in chemistry and industry. For the United States, for example, industry used around 40% of the 65 million tonnes a year. True, Bangladesh isn’t going to have much problem with the largest use, de-icing roads. But the food industry was only 3% of all usage in the US. Limiting ourselves to only domestic production for those historic food reasons would imply limiting heavy industry for no good reason.

And, of course, it would be limiting. If domestically produced salt is as good and as cheap as imported, then it doesn’t need protection from the imports. It’s only if it’s more expensive that we can even talk of requiring tariffs and other limits, isn’t it? 

The answer here is just that there’s a general belief that all the things that can be produced domestically should be produced domestically. Which isn’t the point at all. Rather, we always want to get whatever it is from the cheapest source. 

There is no merit to domestic production at all. No, that domestic workers gain the income from producing it isn’t a benefit. Because wages in Bangladesh are determined by the average productivity in Bangladesh. If we protect inefficient domestic industries like salt, then we are lowering productivity and thus wages across the country.

Given the thousands of suppliers out there, there’s also no strategic reason for domestic production. In fact, other than the fact that the state minister for industries was talking to salt producers, there’s no reason for the policy at all. Therefore, obviously, we shouldn’t have it. 

After all, what is the good to come from making Bangladeshi households pay more for their salt? Other than to please salt producers that is? 


Tim Worstall is a Senior Fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.